Christian Transhumanist Pastor Who Says AI Is Outrunning Our Wisdom | Rev. Dr. Christopher Benek
Hosted by Mykel Salomon · Featuring Christopher Benek · Published
Mykel Salomon is the founder of The Human Protocol Group, creator of The Human Protocol Framework, and host of The Human Protocol Podcast. He explores how technological change affects human beings, and what it takes to stay human while building the future.
Guest: Christopher Benek — Rev. Dr. Christopher J. Benek is a pastor, AI thought leader, and global expert at the intersection of Christianity and emerging technology. He is the CEO of CoCreators and serves as pastor of First Miami Presbyterian Church. Chris has been featured in outlets like The New York Times, BBC, and NPR, and helps leaders, churches, and organizations navigate the ethical, cultural, and spiritual implications of artificial intelligence and the future of humanity.
We keep asking what AI can do. Christopher Benek asks what it is doing to us. By the time you walk into a room, an algorithm has already shaped what you trust, what you fear, and who you think you are. It is not informing you. It is forming you. Benek is a pastor in Miami, one of the world's foremost clergy voices on AI, author of The Church Leader's Guide to Artificial Intelligence, and the first ordained Christian transhumanist in the world. He spends his life at an intersection almost nobody occupies well: ancient faith and emerging technology. His central question is the one most people are quietly circling. What happens when our intelligence races ahead of our wisdom? Host Mykel Salomon and Christopher Benek go a long way into that question. Why wisdom is almost never found in solitude, and what that says about a handful of companies making decisions for everyone. Why being first and being first doing something well are not the same thing. Why he thinks AI is not yet in the hands of enough people. What he sees in AI's theological answers that tells him exactly who is using it. Why the older people in his church want the upgrade and the younger ones do not. And why he is still a tech optimist after all of it. There is also a story about a man who recognized a church building while driving through Brickell, walked in, heard Benek's voice, and realized he had been attending Bible study with him for months inside VR without either of them knowing what the other looked like. His advice at the end is two words long. Chapters: 00:00 Not informing you. Forming you 02:20 Why a pastor ended up in the AI conversation 05:55 Christian transhumanism, and the version he argues against 09:41 “Don't trust pastors” 13:55 Intelligence is cheap. Wisdom takes time 16:23 Separation of powers, and the ability to harm at scale 17:24 Being first, or being first doing it well 18:18 Why wisdom is never found in solitude 21:42 You cannot opt out of this 26:28 Every model carries its makers' fingerprints 29:27 The marathon he ran at 49, and what AI could not do 32:49 Is the game still fun when every stat line is 100 36:15 The man who found his church inside VR 38:23 Older people want the upgrade. Younger people don't 39:07 “We're God's AI” 43:20 What does soul even mean 45:19 The humility of not knowing 51:14 Pricing tiers, and who gets left behind 01:06:45 Maybe toil was never the point 01:16:23 The garbage in Brickell 01:18:57 UBI, and the trust problem underneath it 01:23:33 The Gilded Age became the robber barons 01:27:17 Do the work About the guest Rev. Dr. Christopher Benek is a pastor in Miami and one of the world's foremost clergy voices on artificial intelligence. He is the author of The Church Leader's Guide to Artificial Intelligence and the first ordained Christian transhumanist in the world. His work sits at the intersection of ancient faith and emerging technology, asking what human beings are becoming as the tools we build become more capable. Connect with Rev. Dr. Christopher Benek LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/christopherbenek/ Website: https://www.christopherbenek.com/ Thinking about implementing AI in your business? Download Mykel Salomon's free 10-Step AI Strategy & Execution Roadmap to clarify the business problem, identify the right opportunities, decide what should remain human, and move from idea to execution. Clarity first. Tools second. Humans always: https://dub.sh/thp-roadmap-yt Technology is changing quickly. The human questions matter just as much. Subscribe to The Human Protocol newsletter for weekly perspectives on AI, leadership, work, and what it means to stay human while building the future: https://act-3-agency.link/thp-news-yt ------------ ABOUT THE HOST Mykel Salomon is the founder of The Human Protocol Group, creator of The Human Protocol Framework, and host of The Human Protocol Podcast. He explores how technological change affects human beings, and what it takes to stay human while building the future. CONNECT WITH MYKEL Website: https://thehumanprotocolgroup.com LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/mykelsalomon Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/thehumanprotocolpodcast TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@thehumanprotocol
Conversation Summary
In episode 60 of The Human Protocol Podcast, Rev. Dr. Christopher Benek engages in a deep exploration of the intersection between faith, technology, and humanity. Hosting a conversation rich with insights, Mykel Salomon and Benek delve into the ethical quandaries that arise when technological advancement surpasses moral understanding. They discuss whether wisdom can keep pace with intelligence, how religious communities can navigate the evolving landscape of AI, and the philosophical implications of merging technology with humanity. Benek, a pioneer in Christian transhumanism, argues that technology doesn't only inform us but actively shapes our realities, challenging the status quo of religious thought and societal norms.
“So my understanding of the Christian tradition is that Christ started a redemptive process that we're called to participate in, right?”
— Rev. Dr. Christopher Benek, guest of The Human Protocol
The Distinction Between Christian and Secular Transhumanism Matters
Rev. Dr. Christopher Benek highlights that secular transhumanism often focuses on individual enhancement and superiority, while Christian transhumanism envisions communal upliftment aligned with spiritual truths. This distinction suggests a more inclusive and morally anchored vision for technological integration.
AI Influences Our Reality More Than We Realize
Benek suggests that algorithms do more than provide information; they shape our fears, identities, and beliefs. His insights remind us that understanding the profound influence of AI on personal and societal levels is crucial to navigating its development and integration.
“Well and the other piece of wisdom is it usually isn't always found in solitude.”
— Rev. Dr. Christopher Benek, guest of The Human Protocol
Wisdom is a Collective Pursuit, Not Found in Isolation
The conversation underscores how wisdom is often derived from community interaction rather than individual solitude. Benek argues that religious congregations, with their diverse perspectives, can provide valuable insights into ethical AI development.
A Diversity of Perspectives Enhances Ethical AI Conversations
Benek stresses the importance of involving diverse voices in AI ethics discussions to avoid homogeneous decision-making. Community-based insights are essential in determining the best ways to integrate AI in ways that serve the common good.
Transhumanism is Compatible with Christianity
Despite some religious apprehension towards AI and technological enhancement, Benek believes that faith can harmonize with technology. He envisions a future where human evolution through technology aligns with spiritual narratives of growth and a deepened understanding of humanity.
“Or maybe God gave us the tools to be able to live longer?”
— Rev. Dr. Christopher Benek, guest of The Human Protocol
Final Thoughts
Ultimately, Rev. Dr. Christopher Benek emphasizes the need for caution, humility, and community discourse in intersecting faith with AI. Technology should serve humanity's greater good, guiding us towards moral, ethical, and inclusive applications. By retaining a sense of collective wisdom and engaging in transparent discussions, societies can better navigate the vast potential and risks of emerging technologies.
Key Takeaways
- The Distinction Between Christian and Secular Transhumanism Matters
- AI Influences Our Reality More Than We Realize
- Wisdom is a Collective Pursuit, Not Found in Isolation
- A Diversity of Perspectives Enhances Ethical AI Conversations
- Transhumanism is Compatible with Christianity
Frequently Asked Questions
What is Christian transhumanism?
Christian transhumanism is a movement that believes in enhancing human capabilities through technology, guided by Christian moral and ethical principles.
Why does Rev. Dr. Christopher Benek think AI is more than just a tool?
Benek argues that AI not only informs us but actively shapes our realities, including our fears, perceptions, and identities.
How can religious communities contribute to AI ethics?
Religious communities, through their diverse and ethically anchored perspectives, can offer valuable insights and a moral compass for AI development and usage.
What are the risks of secular transhumanism according to Benek?
Benek warns that secular transhumanism might promote individualism and superiority, diverging from communal upliftment and moral responsibility.
How should societies address the rapid pace of technological advancement?
Societies should engage in community-based discussions that include diverse perspectives, fostering wisdom and ethical standards to guide the integration of technology like AI.
Full Episode Transcript
This is the full recorded conversation from The Human Protocol Podcast, published by The Human Protocol Group. © 2026 The Human Protocol Group. Please link to and attribute the original episode when referencing this conversation.
HOST MP3 (00:14.294) Yeah. Yeah. GUEST MP3 (00:25.336) Calling three, two, one Three, two, one. We keep asking what AI can do, but my guest today is asking a different type of question. What is it doing to us? He's a pastor, arguably the world's leading one on AI. And he says by the time you walk into any room, and he says by the time that happens, an algorithm has already shaped what you trust, what you fear, and who you think you are. Not inform you. We keep asking what AI can do, but my guest today is asking a different type of question. What is it doing to us? He's a pastor, arguably the world's leading one on AI. And he says by the time you walk into any room, and he says, by the time that happens, an algorithm has already shaped what you trust, what you fear. And who you think you are, not inform you, but form you. So stay with me. Welcome to the Human Protocol, the podcast about staying human while building the future where leaders, operators, and humans from every walk of life come to ask and answer one question, which is how do we build the future without losing ourselves? I am your host, Michael Solomon. My guest brings a lens this show hasn't had yet. So this is the first time for us. HOST MP3 (00:59.756) But form you. So stay with me. Welcome to the Human Protocol, the podcast about staying human while building the future, where leaders, operators, and humans from every walk of life come to ask and answer one question, which is how do we build the future without losing ourselves? I am your host, Michael Solomon. My guest brings a lens this show hasn't had yet. So this is the first time for us. Reverend Dr. Christopher Bennett. Reverend Dr. Christopher Bennick is a pastor right here in Miami and one of the world's foremost clergy voices on AI. He's the CEO of Co-Creators, the author of The Church Leader's Guide to AI, and the first ordained Christian, transhumanist in the world. He spent his life at the intersection almost no one occupies very well. is a pastor right here in Miami and one of the world's foremost clergy voices on AI. He's the CEO of Co-Creators, the author of The Church Leader's Guide to AI, and the first ordained Christian transhumanist in the world. He spent his life at the intersection almost no one occupies very well, ancient faith and emerging technology, and his central question Ancient faith and emerging technology and his central question is one every human I know is quietly circling around, which is what happens when our intelligence races ahead of our wisdom. Chris, welcome to the human protocol. It's a pleasure to have you on. Yeah, thanks for having me. Thank you, appreciate that. So why AI for you and Is one every human I know is quietly circling around, which is what happens when our intelligence races ahead of our wisdom. Chris, welcome to the Human Protocol. It's a pleasure to have you on. Yeah, thanks for having me. Thank you, appreciate that. So why AI for you? And HOST MP3 (02:20.096) Why do you think your voice it's important today more than ever, especially on what you do and your faith and and and your ability and capacity to connect with other human beings? Well Why do you think your voice it's important today more than ever, especially on what you do and your faith and and and your ability and capacity to connect with other human beings? Well, I I kind of fell into AI actually. I I was in Ohio serving a congregation there and I was introduced to a movie called Bigger Stronger Faster Bigger Faster Stronger. but it w it was it was a book or it was a it was a movie that was based on was a doc documentary based on the Bell Brothers. And the Bell Brothers were exploring what human enhancement had That was based on HOST MP3 (02:58.476) The Bell brothers were exploring what human enhancement had meant for people. And there was one brother, they were they were power lifters in the and there was one brother that was meant for people. And there was one brother, they were they were powerlifters in the and there was one brother that was against steroid use, anabolic steroid use. And then there were two other brothers that were really into anabolic steroid use. And the movie movie was fascinating because the way it was produced it it talked about the ethics of against steroid use, anabolic steroid use. And then there were two other brothers that were really into anabolic steroid use. And the movie movie was fascinating because the way it was produced it it talked about the ethics of of us and why we see some things as acceptable and why we think other things might not be. And so it was fascinating to me as they they drew comparisons between people like Tiger Woods of us and why we see some things as acceptable and why we think other things might not be. And so it was fascinating to me as they they drew comparisons between people like Tiger Woods who had LASIK eye surgery because he was considered almost legally blind and and they said well we're we want to use this to better ourselves. How is it fair that Tiger Woods in a game that where sight is really important Had LASIK eye surgery because he was considered almost legally blind. And and they said, Well, we're we want to use this to better ourselves. How is it fair that Tiger Woods, in a game that where sight is really important, can can have this upgrade to himself that he wouldn't naturally have? How is it that Lionel Messi can take human growth hormone when he's young and not nearly? GUEST MP3 (03:58.966) Can can have this upgrade to himself that he wouldn't naturally have. How is it that Lionel Messi can take human growth hormone when he's young and not nearly as qualified a player as he is now? But as soon as he takes that, he instantly becomes one of the world's best players. As qualified a player as he is now, but as soon as he takes that, he instantly becomes one of the world's best players. They weren't taking away the fact that you have to put work in, but they were saying we use things to enhance ourselves all the time. And as I started getting into that more and more, I started looking at what the intersection of humanity and technology is and kind of always has been, and where that might be going. They weren't taking away the fact that you have to put work in, but they were saying we use things to enhance ourselves all the time. and as I started getting into that more and more, I started looking at what the intersection of humanity and technology is and kind of always has been and where that might be going. And classic faith traditions talk about who we are as people. And classic faith traditions talk about who we are as people. And and so this intersection seemed to be kind of a natural fit because we have a lot of assumptions as to who we are, but who are we becoming? and and ancient traditions have opinions that. We all have opinions on that, right? Let's start there, 'cause you know, it's a it's a very interesting and fascinating topic. And and so this intersection seemed to be kind of a natural fit because we have a lot of assumptions as to who we are, but who are we becoming? and and ancient traditions have opinions on that. We all have opinions on that. That's right. That's right. That's right. Let's start there, because you know it's a it's a very interesting and fascinating topic from my point of view because I HOST MP3 (05:09.88) From my point of view, because I know that you consider yourself a transhumanist, right? And transhumanism is that movement that believes we can enhance with biotechnology, with the help of technology, and prolong our years and our life past our human and biological limitations. Not everybody within your religion believes or thinks that that's right. Consider yourself a transhumanist. Yes. And transhumanism is that movement that believe we can enhance with biotechnology, with the help of technology. years in our life past our human and biological limitations. Not everybody within your religion believes or thinks that that's right. Right. What would you tell those? Well I think first it's really important to distinguish between transhumanism and Christian transhumanism. So there's a secular transhumanism that I've actually argued against, which is part of why I What would you tell those? distinguish between transhumanism and Christian transhumanism. So there's a secular transhumanism that I've actually argued against which is part of why GUEST MP3 (05:55.564) was critical in helping to found the Christian transhumanist movement. because secular transhumanism has a very will the power Nietzschean kind of element about it where you can have the the Superman and and you you can become better than other people. Whereas Christian theology the goal is not to be better than other people. the it's it's a high tide raises all ships kind of mentality. So my understanding of the Christian tradition is that Christ started a redemptive process that we're called to participate in, right? And when you look and if you take seriously some of GM. Superman and and you you can become better than other people. Whereas Christian theology the goal is not to be better than other people. the it's it's a high tide raises all ships kind of mentality. So my understanding of the Christian tradition is that Christ started a redemptive process that we're called to participate in, right? And when you look and if you take seriously some of the claims of Christianity, they're fantastical. There are things that there's a reason it's faith, right? Because there are things that we can't empirically prove. Now, I'll I'll make the distinction. It doesn't mean that there isn't data that we receive, because when we talk about proving something from a scientific standpoint, we talk about how can we put it through the scientific method. GUEST MP3 (06:35.054) the claims of Christianity, they're fantastical. There are things that there's a reason it's faith, right? Because there are things that we can't empirically prove. Now, I'll I'll make the distinction. It doesn't mean that there isn't data that we receive, because when we talk about proving something from a scientific standpoint, we talk about how can we put it through the scientific method. But but when we but when we think about But but when we but when we think about the data that we receive on a daily basis, you have a lot of revelatory data, things that only you experience that you can't test over and over. And so at some point we have to say, well, is that revelatory data information that we should process that we should consider? And it's actually not very scientific to not consider it, because you consider all the data, whether you can pr test it or not. So in in Christian circles, we have this very interesting phenomenon, The data that we receive on a daily basis, you have a lot of revelatory data. Things that only you experience that you can't test over and over. And so at some point we have to say, well, is that revelatory data information that we should process that we should consider? And it's actually not very scientific to not consider it, because you consider all the data, whether you can test it. Prove it or not. So in in Christian circles, we have this very interesting phenomenon. account of Jesus dying and being resurrected, whatever the heck that means. And when Jesus is resurrected, he's different than he was. He's some in some ways he's like us, but in some ways he's different than than than we are. And HOST MP3 (07:34.85) Jesus dying and being resurrected, whatever the heck that means. And when Jesus is resurrected, he's different than he was. He's some in some ways he's like us, but in some ways he's different than than than we are. And some of those ways that he's like us is he's physical. He tells at least Thomas in the gospel accounts to put his hand in his side and touch him. Some of those ways that he's like us is he's physical. He tells at least Thomas and the in the gospel accounts to put his hand in his side and touch him. he's hungry. He that's like a hilarious thing about I mean, there's a lot of hilarious things in the Bible. But there's others that change. So he he he walks with people, he's hungry. He that's like a hilarious thing about I mean there's a lot of hilarious things so there are parts of him that remain him but there others that changed. But there's others that change. So he he he walks And they don't recognize who he is until he performs the ritual action of breaking bread. It's almost like he shapeshifter Jesus. And they're they're right with him, but but they don't know who he is. He he has glorified wounds, whatever that means. So the wounds of his crucifixion have somehow been glorified in him. So he he can walk through locked doors. And they don't recognize who he is until he performs the ritual action of breaking bread. It's almost like a shapeshifter Jesus. And they're they're right with him, but but they don't know who he is. He he has glorified wounds, whatever that means. So the wounds of his crucifixion have somehow been glorified in him. So he he can walk through locked doors. He ascends into heaven. I don't know what that means. But but the fundamental point of that is is that there's something there that HOST MP3 (08:39.534) He ascends into heaven. I don't know what that means. But but the fundamental point of that is that there's something there that articulates that humanity changes and grows, which is not foreign from our experience of who we are now. Right? You're not the same as you were when you were five. You're not the same as you were when you were a teenager. You're not the same as you were a few years ago. and and you won't be the same as you are. articulates that humanity changes and grows, which is not foreign from our experience of who we are now, right? you're not the same as you were when you were five. you're not the same as you were when you were a teenager. You're not the same as you were a few years ago. and and you won't be the same as you are ten years from now. That's right. So if you believe that this is a season and there's something eternal, right? There's there's a ten years. Change has always been the constant. That's right. So if you believe that this is a season and there's something eternal, right? There's there's a reality that we will change. And the question then becomes well what is technology's role in that change? And is it a hermeneutic or a lens that we have where we assume that our existence as we know it is fixed, or might it be the case that there are some things that we categorize that we might be able reality that we will change. And the question then becomes, well what is technology's role in that change? And is it a hermeneutic or a lens that we have where we assume that our existence as we know it is fixed, or might it be the case that there are some things that we categorize that we might be able to think about in different ways, and I would argue technological ways. think about in different ways and I would argue technological ways. Hm. Where where do you think your church is in all of that? Fifty fifty, the majority thinking like you, a lot of work to do to to people understand more of what that really means for us? Yeah. GUEST MP3 (09:41.518) do you think your church is in all of that? Fifty fifty, the majority thinking like you, a lot of work to do to do people understand more of what that really means for us? Yeah, I mean w well one thing we try to do is be really honest with people to say like 'cause Christianity's pretty hilarious in some ways. Like w we we we act like we have it all together. And there's churches that are like, this is the way that it is, but but that's not my experience of Christianity. for an example, angels. Like people dress their children up as angels in Christmas plates. We send cards with angels, we have enlightenment pictures of angels, what we think they're looking like. but Christianity is pretty hilarious in some ways. Like we we we we act like we have it all together. And there's churches that are like this is the way that it is, but but that's not my experience of Christianity. For example, angels. Like people dress their children up as angels in Christmas plates. We send cards with angels, we have enlightenment pictures of angels, what we think they're looking like. But what do we really know about an angel? You and I What do we really know about an angel? You and I could sit here for three hours and talk about what do we think an angel is and probably not get much further in the conversation. Be we we have some basic information about them. we we know that they must be a little scary to people because they always tell people do not fear at the beginning. But but the the thing is, is there are so many things that we don't have the answer to. So one, we start with a as a Sit here for three hours and talk about what do we think of angelism, probably not get much further in the conversation. Because they always tell people do not fear at the beginning. But but the the thing is is there are so many things that we don't have the answer to. So one, we start with a as a at a place of honesty to just say, look, there are lots of questions we don't know the answer to. We're in that together. That's why we're here to explore together. I don't have all the answers. GUEST MP3 (10:52.46) at a place of honesty to just say, look, there are lots of questions we don't know the answer to. We're in that together. That's why we're here to explore together. I don't have all the answers. Don't take my word for it. I I tell people all the time, because we're in South Florida, don't trust pastors. There's been like church scandals in every major denomination in South Florida. so so when it comes to technology, we start from that position to say, well, where are you with technology? What are the questions that you have with qu technology? And that's part of why I wrote Don't take my word for it. I tell people all the time, because we're in South Florida, don't trust pastors. There's been like church scandals in every major denomination in South Florida. So when it comes to technology, we start from that position to say, well, where are you with technology? What are the questions that you have with technology? And that's part of why I wrote The Church Leader's Guide to Artificial Intelligence, because what I realized is we had an initial gathering of people talking about artificial intelligence. The Church Leader's Guide to Artificial Intelligence because what I realized is we had an initial gathering of people talking about artificial intelligence, and they were all over the place. and what I found, and and I kind of found it organically, that I was holding people together in this conversation because I knew the particulars of who they are. So I had another meeting at one point, and I had them meet, and I had someone else moderate that meeting, and And they were all over the place. and what I found and and I kinda found it organically that I was holding people together in this conversation because I knew the particulars of who they are. Right. So I had another meeting at one point. had them meet and I had someone else moderate that meeting and almost everyone came out of that meeting going, Past you can't miss another meeting because that was terrible. And it was because they're all over the place. So the framework that I try to provide is not to say here's some prescriptive way to think about AI, but it's instead to ask questions about AI and to get them to start thinking about it. And that has been really well received. So in Lent we did the first three chapters of the book. GUEST MP3 (11:50.614) Almost everyone came out of that meeting going, Pastor, you can't miss another meeting because that was terrible. And it was because they're all over the place. So the framework that I try to provide is not to say, here's some prescriptive way to think about AI, but it's instead to ask questions about AI and to get them to start thinking about it. And that has been really well received. So in Lent we did the first three chapters of the book. We had about thirty people who who gathered all different We had about 30 people who who gathered all different backgrounds. Some have zero. They're like amateur AI folks. Some people using it all the time in their work. Everybody using it in some sense, whether they knew it or not. background, some have zero, they're like amateur AI folks, some people using it all the time in their work, everybody using it in some sense, whether they knew it or not. and and having them think about these questions together in community and they loved it. and and so I actually I've the the challenge I've had is because we're so busy and the church has been growing so much is I've got a bunch of people saying when are we going to do the continue on with the AI class. And so that's what we're in the process of trying to figure out right now. and having them think about these questions together in community and they loved it. and and so I actually I've the the challenge I've had is because we're so busy and the church has been growing so much, is I've got a bunch of people saying what are we gonna do the continue on with the AI class? And so that's what we're in the process of trying to figure out right now. That's awesome because I I also believe the more we have people asking questions, the better That's awesome because I I also believe the more we have people asking questions, the better because that's how we humans is try to start understanding what's h going on with. HOST MP3 (12:56.94) Because that's how we humans try to start understanding what's ho going on with things. And I and I don't think we are asking a lot of questions today. I I really would like people to ask more questions, not only be on the receiving side of things, because they're receiving a lot of noise from the news without knowing what to do with it, right? And questions allow you to get to the level of where people are and understand when they are and then build from that moment on. things and I and I don't think we're asking a lot of questions today. I really would like people to ask more questions, not only be on the receiving side of things, but they're receiving a lot of noise from the news without knowing what to do with it. Right? And questions allow you to get to the level of where people are and understand when they are and then build from that moment on. And and I think it is important that that that we keep people and pushing people to ask more questions. one thing that I want to ask you because I know that this is something that that that you talk a lot about, that differentiation of intelligence and wisdom and why is it's a real danger that we need to pay attention to. Because we have a lot of intelligence, right? That is available to us right now. Not a lot of wisdom. And and I think it is important that that that we keep people and pushing people to ask more questions. one thing that I want to ask you because I know that this is something that that that you talk a lot about, that differentiation of intelligence and wisdom and why is is a real danger that we need to pay attention to. Because we have a lot of intelligence, right, that is available to us right now. Not a lot of wisdom being developed. And that gap the wider it gets, the more dangerous can become. Yeah. Well I I think when we think about wisdom HOST MP3 (13:55.81) being developed. And that gap the wider it gets, the more dangerous can become. GUEST MP3 (14:07.624) One thing that ancient traditions really help is they've had a lot of trial and error, right? So I I'd be the first person to say, there are lots of things that the church has done wrong, and those are things that the church we should be apologizing for. because the church didn't really represent Jesus. I like I found most people really don't have a co have a problem with Jesus or God or someone believing in Jesus or God. What they have a problem with are the people Mm-hmm. So I I'd be the first person to say there are lots of things that the church Things that HOST MP3 (14:23.788) The church didn't really represent Jesus. I like I found most people really Jesus or God or someone believing in Jesus or God, what they have a problem with are the people who claim to represent Jesus or God, right? And and and I think that's a valid critique. And so so as as we as we enter into having conversations with people, part part of what we want to think about is is to say, well, how can that ancient wisdom Who claim to represent Jesus or God, right? And and and I think that's a valid critique. And so so as as we as we enter into having conversations with people, part part of what we want to think about is is to say, well, how can that ancient wisdom, those that ancient experience inform what we should do today? And and I think to discount the experience of humanity, and that's not just in religious traditions, it's we've seen that that all throughout. That ancient experience inform what we should do today. And and I think to discount the experience of humanity, and that's not just in religious traditions, it's we've seen that that all throughout history. There are things that we need to be careful that we we don't repeat. We know we know we have failed at some things, and so for us to be discerning, well, what does that look like and how do we history there things that we need to be careful that we we don't repeat we know we know we have failed at some things and so for us to be discerning well what does that look like and how do we how do we do that you know that that that's what that's what we want to be thinking through so so as it pertains to wisdom it's like you know is technology how have we seen technology HOST MP3 (15:21.176) do that. You know, that that that's what that's what we want to be thinking through. So so as it pertains to wisdom, it's like you know, is technology, how have we seen technology used before? And what are the ways that we need to think about technology? used before and what are the ways that we need to think about technology as we move forward because the church has some experience on this. And and I think the other thing is is we need to distinguish between just having a lot of information b then as opposed to knowing what to do with it. Right. And I hear a lot of tech because the church has some experience on this. And and I think the other thing is is we need to distinguish between just having a lot of information as opposed to knowing what to do with it. Do with it. Right. And I hear a lot of tech Gurus or giants, heads of companies who speak as though they have wisdom, but as soon as you hear them, you you kind of go, yeah, there's something wrong there. And and if you find an elder person in a church, a lot of times they'll have a yuck factor with that. And and when you talk more about it, you'll you'll get to what it is. And a lot of times it's a a position of hubris, frankly. It's to say somehow they know the answer, they know what the future is when they're playing with something. Heads of companies who speak as though they have wisdom, but as soon as you hear them, you you kind of go, yeah, there's something wrong there. And if you find an elder person in a church, a lot of times they'll have a yuck factor with that. And if you talk more about it, you'll get to what it is. And a lot of times it's a a position of hubris, frankly. HOST MP3 (16:23.412) It's to say somehow they know the answer, they know what the future is when they're playing with something that affects a lot of people. and in my tradition, the Presbyterian tradition, what we've learned in the middle of all that is that there's a reason that we have separation of powers, right? Is because any one person has too much power, even with the best of intention, they have the ability to harm people to scale. That affects a lot of people. And in my tradition, the Presbyterian tradition, what we've learned in the middle of all that is that there's a reason that we have separation of powers, right? Is because any one person has too much power, even with the best of intention, they have the ability to harm people to scale more often. And so part of the wisdom of this is actually kind of walking cautiously as we work through what these issues are. And so part of the wisdom of this is actually kind of walking cautiously as we work through what these issues are. And and that becomes a challenge, as you know, with technology, because there are motivators to be first. And and that becomes a challenge, as you know, with technology because there are motivators to be first. and but the question is is is it is the best thing to be first or is it to be first doing something well? And and I think there's a big distinction between that because you can be first and have a really bad outcome. and and so th those are the things for us. Right. But the question is is is it is the best thing to be first or is it to be first doing something well? And and I think there's a big distinction between that because you can be first and have a really bad outcome. and and so th those are the things for us to consider. Yeah. And and you know, I think a lot of people are just trying to be first. I think a lot of people today, especially with the help of AI, they are GUEST MP3 (17:24.204) to consider. Yeah, and and you know, I think a lot of people are just trying to be first. I think a lot of people today, especially with the help of AI, they are using their platforms and their power and their following base to just put things out there that when you look at it, they lack substance. They're not based in fact. using their platforms and their power and their following base to just put things out there that when you look at it, they lack substance, they're not based in fact. But the wisdom of it all takes time to build. And intelligence is being developed so quick. And the catch-up between both of them, it takes time for you to develop and for you to grow that type of wisdom. But the wisdom of it all takes time to build. And intelligence is being developed so quick. And the catch up between both of them, it takes time for you to develop and for you to grow the type of wisdom that you will like on human beings for us to make the best decisions that we can. But I don't think anyone not anyone That you would like on human beings for us to make the best decisions that we can. But I don't think anyone n not anyone th let's not generalize, right? That's not never good. But I don't think for a lot of people they are too worried about developing wisdom rather than becoming a center of attention and using AI to leverage their agenda or whatever they want to. Let's not generalize, right? There's not never good. But I don't think for a lot of people they are too worried about developing wisdom rather than GUEST MP3 (18:18.22) becoming a center of attention and using AI to leverage their agenda or whatever they want to. Well and the other piece of wisdom is it usually isn't always found in solitude. Right. Right? It's it's found in community of some sort, which is where the church actually has an interesting place. You know, the the person that you think is least likely to give you the wise thing oftentimes gives you the insight that you didn't have that that always found in solitude. Right. It's it's found in community. Right. The church actually has an interesting place. You know, the the person that you think is least likely to give you the wise thing oftentimes gives you the insight that you didn't have, that that helps collectively to bring a perspective that no one considered. And so where is that happening? You know, when when you have open AI anthropic It helps collectively to bring a perspective that no one considered. And so where is that happening? You know, when when you have OpenAI anthropic grok, any of these, pick your LLM company of choice, like what is the corporate decision making that's based in wisdom? And usually it's from a siloed position, right? It's it's a single group of people. and and that's been another thing. Like my congregation represents Any of these, you pick your LLM company of choice, like what is the corporate decision making that's based in wisdom? And usually it's from a siloed position, right? It's it's a single group of people. Right. and and that's been another thing. Like my congregation represents more than 50 different nationalities. So we have people from all over the world, they speak different languages, they have very different cultural perspectives. And when you talk about scripture, for example, More than 50 different nationalities. So we have people from all over the world. They speak different languages. They have very different cultural perspectives. And when you talk about scripture, for example, their perspective on the scripture is wildly different from one another. So I tell them all the time like, don't just take my word for it. Like, talk with one another. So on Sunday I'll preach and I'll preach because it's part of my responsibilities there. But then on Wednesday, they had the same scripture and they have Bible. HOST MP3 (19:29.994) their perspective on the scriptures wildly different from one another. So I I tell them all the time, like don't just take my word for it. Like s talk with one another. So on Sunday I'll preach, and I'll preach because it's part of my responsibilities there. But then on Wednesday, they had the same scripture and they have Bible studies where they talk about these in community. We use the same format that we use on Wednesdays as we were talking about AI to have community discussions about. So it's not about what does the pastor think about it, it's what does the community think. And based on your experience and your wisdom, how do how do we think about those things? The other challenge is that people like the Bible studies where they talk about these in community. We use the same format that we use on Wednesdays as we were talking about AI to have community discussions about. So it's not about what does the pastor think about it. It's what does the community think? And based on your experience and your wisdom, how do how do we think about those things? The other challenge is that people like to generalize the nuance of religion. And so, for example, Anthropic has gathered together generalize the nuance of religion. And so for example, Anthropic has gathered together Christian experts to to get in a room and and talk about things. Christian experts to to get in a room and and talk about things regarding AI and what should happen. But that feels a bit more like pacifying the public to me, because if you actually look at who's in that conversation, it's mostly Catholics and evangelicals, which anthropic might not have a big diversity of Yeah. Anthropic maybe they only, you know, they only know what they know, right? But HOST MP3 (20:24.488) AI and what should happen. But that feels a bit more like pacifying the public to me because if you actually look at who's in that conversation, it's mostly Catholics and evangelicals. Which anthropic might there's not a big diversity of being Yeah, anthropic maybe GUEST MP3 (20:44.92) they they can put in their own AI and ask what would diversity on this subject matter in this area look and it will give them a response that's deeper than what they're practicing. And and so the the reality is is we have to think through the particulars of these things. And that doesn't always mean it's at light speed. It it means doing things well as as opposed to just going fast and being first. They they can put in their own AI and ask what would diversity on this subject matter in this area look, and it will give them a response that's deeper than what they're practicing. And so the the reality is we have to think through the particulars of these things, and that doesn't always mean it's at light speed. It it means doing things well as opposed to just going fast and being firm. Yeah, and and and Chris I know that you have written a lot about the state of how the church in in in general look at AI and how sometimes may be too dismissive, too afraid of you know, the things that can go wrong, right, instead of the things that we may be missing, right? In in all this conversation on how it is actually shaping us. Yeah, and and and Chris I know that you have written a lot about the state of how the church in in in general look at AI and how sometimes be too dismissive, too afraid of, you know, the things that can go wrong, right? instead of the things that we may be missing right in in all this conversation on how it is actually shaping us. HOST MP3 (21:42.83) how it is forming us, which which I know I that I know that it's something that you pay a lot of attention to. Where where is this conversation today? Well it's fascinating 'cause I s I s have the privilege of speaking all over the place and I and I play well with others, so I speak in many different denominations, in different religious traditions even. And it's fascinating to me how much just sheer rejection of AI there is. There are a lot of people who were forming us which I know I that I know that it's something that you pay a lot of attention to. Where where is this conversation today? Well it's fascinating 'cause I s I s have the privilege of speaking all over the place and I and I play well with others so I speak in many different denominations and different religious traditions even. And it's fascinating to me how much just sheer rejection of AI there is. There are a lot of people who are very scared of AI. they Very scared of AI. Or like, no, no, no. And without kind of going down you know, too far in comparisons, but there is kind of a light Ludditeism in in some of this thinking. And and part of what I try to reframe and help shift people's perspectives with is for them to understand that And without kinda going down. HOST MP3 (22:21.61) But there is kind of a light Ludditeism in some of this thinking. And part of what I try to reframe and help shift people's perspectives with is for them to understand that this is not something you can opt out of. This is not something you can opt out of and have it not affect you. it it's gonna affect you no matter what. this is like Amish or Mennonite traditions trying to get away from society. R really, they can do it in s to some degree, but they can't do it completely. so what I've encouraged people is to say, look, you're using AI all the time now, whether you know it or not. if you refuse to It it's gonna affect you no matter what. this is like Amish or Mennonite traditions trying to get away from society. Really, they can do it in s to some degree, but they can't do it completely. so what I've encouraged people is to say, look, you're using AI all the time now, whether you know it or not. if you refuse to have a conversation about it. To have a conversation about it, what's gonna happen is your voice isn't gonna be heard. And you're then gonna forfeit your right to shape the conversation. And so I think it's it's important for as we talk with people to encourage them and to educate them in ways that empower them. Because for me, I like one one challenge I I see, you know, I'm a white guy originally from Ohio. I think AI is not in What's gonna happen is your voice isn't gonna be heard and you're then gonna forfeit your right to shape the conversation. And so I think it's it's important for as we talk with people to encourage them and to educate them in ways that empower them. Because for me, I like one one challenge I I see, you know, I'm a white guy originally from Ohio. I think AI is not in the hands of enough diversity. GUEST MP3 (23:37.056) hands of enough diversity at this point. there are not an there are not and and I'm not really seeing a big effort on the part of big companies to actually change that. There they they might bring people into their circle, so to speak, but then you're expected to play in that circle. Whereas Yeah. At this point. There are not an there are not, and and I'm not really seeing a big effort on the part of big companies to actually change that. They might bring people into their circle, so to speak, but then you're expected to play in that circle. Whereas we, I think, need to go into communities and talk about well, how is this impacting people? We I think need to go into communities and talk about well how is this impacting people? because it's a business at the end of the day. So they're w the only worry right now is just to make sure that they make a lot money. They make a lot of money and and the problem is is do they actually have a product too? Because I Because it's a business at the end of the day. So they wore the only worry right now it's just to make sure that they make a lot of money. They make a lot of money. And and the problem is is do they actually have a product too? Because I I don't really see for a lot of AI products that products that are out there, I don't see a sustainability plan for them long term. I think people are investing a lot of money and they aren't they don't know what they I don't really see for a lot of AI products that products that are out there, I don't see a sustainability plan for them long term. I think people are investing a lot of money and they aren't they don't know what they do. And and I think this is a dangerous thing. Like if you're because my church is in the finance and really now a tech area of Miami, and you know, so we have a lot of finance people, and it's fascinating to me how many people HOST MP3 (24:32.81) And and I think this is a dangerous thing. Like if you're because my church is in the finance and really now a tech area of Miami and you know, so we have a lot of finance people and it's fascinating to me how many people given how many people we have in finance, how many people don't have a finance Given how many people we have in finance, how many people don't have a financial plan, for example? And and so when we start thinking about we start thinking about AI and and what the direction it's going in is, it's it's to say, well, what is the plan for people and what is the from a business standpoint, is the plan for AI just simply to And and so when we start thinking about we start thinking about AI and and what the direction it's going in is it's it's to say, well, what is the plan for people and what is the from a business standpoint, is the plan for AI just simply to continue to make money or is it actually continuing to to better people's situation? people financially a lot of times don't realize that, you know, you have to be intentional about your finances if you want your finances to be in a better place. Right. It's the same continue to make money or is it actually continuing to to better people's situation? people financially a lot of times don't realize that, you know, you have to be intentional GUEST MP3 (25:28.736) about your finances if you want your finances to be in a better place. It's the same thing with AI. You have to be intentional with it if you want AI to be this is the same thing with everything in our human reality. If formatively you want to be better, you have to take intentional steps to be better. because it because you can't just sit back and let everything happen to you. That won't go well for you. You have to actually have some agency, make With AI. You have to be intentional with it if you want AI to be this is the same thing with everything in our human reality. If formatively you want to be better, you have to take intentional steps to be better. Because it because you can't just sit back and let everything happen to you. That won't go well for you. You have to actually have some agency, make some decisions and enact those decisions. Now how what decisions you make, the process by which you make those decisions, that's a whole nother conversation. And I think it's an important one. It is. It's at the end of the day, people are talking about A AI as it is a technology problem. It's not. This is a human problem that what we're talking here. How we use it, how we leverage the decisions that we make, our intentionality as as you just mentioned, it's really on us. some decisions and enact those decisions. Now how what decisions you make, the process by which you make those decisions, that's a whole nother conversation. And I think it's an important one. It is. It's at the end of the day people are talking about AI as it is a technology problem. It's not. This is a human problem that what we're talking about. How we use it, how we leverage the decisions that we make, our intentionality as as you just mentioned, it's really on us. The way we teach, the way we work with these AIs. The way we teach, the way we work with these AIs, it's really on us. It's using our data. It's learning from our history, right? GUEST MP3 (26:28.66) It's really on us. It's using our data. It's learning from our history. I mean a great example of this is Grok, right? Grok may be one of the most flippant AIs that that we have, right? And and that's very like characteristic of Elon Musk. You can see where Elon Musk's fingerprints are all over it. All you have to do is follow his ex account and and you can see this, right? So w we'd be foolish to think that that we have, right? And and that's very like characteristic of Elon Musk. You can see where Elon Musk's fingerprints are all over it. All you have to do is follow his X account and and you can see this, right? So we'd be foolish to think that ChatGPT or Claude or or any other system that we might use somehow is not you know somehow is not doesn't have the imprint of the people designing it on it. Chat GPT or Claude or or any other system that we might use somehow is not you know, somehow is not doesn't have the imprint of the people designing it on it. now Now, on top of that, it also has all the information that we're giving it, right? So this is a great example. It's like when I use AI for theological inquiry, right? I can tell the answers by because I'm trained, when it gives me an answer, I can tell you the vast majority of people who are using it. And I can tell you there are way more evangelicals are using it than mainline Christians. On top of that, it also has all the information that we're giving it, right? So this is a great example. It's like when I use AI for theological inquiry, right? I can tell the answers by because I'm trained, when it gives me an answer, I can tell you the vast majority of people who are using it. And I can tell you there way more evangelicals are using it than mainline Christians because of the responses that it gives. HOST MP3 (27:38.498) Because of the responses that it gives. So you already have an adoption rate that you know where I have to go, no, no, no, I'm in the reform tradition. That's not our analogy. Optional rate that you know. That's not our theology. And then it goes, and every once in a while I have to correct it because it forgets. and and so this is it's even with AI, it's a formative thing, but then that's forming me too, because now it's co-creating with me, right? And so pretending that the information that I'm In a while I have to correct it because it forgets. And and so this is it's even with AI, it's a formative thing, but then that's forming me too, because now it's co-creating with me, right? And so pretending that the information that I'm receiving, you know, garbage in, garbage out, that works with people too. Yeah. Right? And and so so like trying to make sure that we know the difference. I don't envy somebody who's you know. receiving, you know, garbage in, garbage out, that works with people too, right? And and so so like trying to make sure that we know the difference. I don't envy somebody who's younger now, because the temptation of of going it, you know, and and like I I had the advantage of Now because the temptation of of going it you know and and like I I had the advantage of just the internet was born as I really was entering into college. It was its widespread use was really just coming about. and so there were certain things we just couldn't rely on. GUEST MP3 (28:30.552) just the internet was born as I really was entering into college. It was its widespread use was really just coming about. and so there were certain things we just couldn't rely on. in the same way and we kinda had to do the old fashioned way and and you know get in a book and know how to look things up and whatever. Those skills now are actually really helpful with AI because you have to check some of that stuff. And and I think what we're gonna see is like someone like my son who's who's eleven, you know, he's intuitively on an iPad, I think since he's like one, you know, he has a very different experience of reality than I do. And and I think in the same way and we kinda had to do the old fashioned way and and get in a book and know how to look things up and whatever. Those skills now are actually really helpful with AI because you have to check some of that stuff. And and I think what we're gonna see is like someone like my son who's who's eleven, you know, he's intuitively on an iPad, I think, since he's like one, you know. He has a very different experience of reality than I do. I think it's gonna be fascinating to see how that shapes him, but also to say then, okay, well what work are you really willing to put in and not forfeit over? because it's important for you it's gonna be fascinating to see how that shapes him but also to say then okay well what work are you really willing to put in and not forfeit over because it's important for you becoming a better version of you right and and so and and there's some like easy places we see this now if you want to get physically healthier my ai can help me to create a plan for that but I still have to HOST MP3 (29:27.19) Better. And so and and there's some like easy places we see this now. if you want to get physically healthier, my AI can help me to create a plan for that, but I still have to actually go out and do the work. I ran and when I say ran, my goal was to finish so I could run and walk. but I did the Hawaii marathon last year. forty nine first marathon ever done. I used AI to help develop Actually, go out and do the work. I ran and when I say ran, my goal was to finish so I needed run walk. but I did the Hawaii marathon last year. 49, first marathon I'd ever done. I used AI to help develop a plan so I could get to the physical level I needed to do that, right? I still had to go out every day and do the work. plan so I could get to the physical world I needed to do that, right? I still had to go out every day and do the work. I'm training to do the Athens marathon this fall. great. you know, but I still have to go out do the work and it you know, and it's really difficult. It's have you done the Miami marathon? I haven't. I'm trying to stay away from where anyone can see me. Now I see. Yeah. No, but but because the thing is for me it's I'm training to do the Athens marathon this fall. you know, but I still have to go out do the work and it you know, and it's really difficult. It's you done the Miami marathon? I haven't. I'm trying to stay away from where anyone can see me do these marathons at this life. Yeah, yeah, yeah. No, but but because the thing is for me it's GUEST MP3 (30:28.064) It's about doing something difficult for myself that I can get that I can get better. And and this is very practical thing when we think about AI. It's like if you're a student, yes, you can use AI to do work, and some of it's busy work or research work and and that I would say that's a great use of AI. But but you won't know your voice if you don't actually start writing and learning how to y It's about doing something difficult for myself that I can get better. And and this is a very practical thing when we think about AI. It's like if you're a student, yes you can use AI to do work, and some of it's busy work or research. GUEST MP3 (30:54.132) what you would be without the AI. It's kind of like being in a good relationship, right? If you don't know that cognitive upload and Yeah. Well if if you're in a relationship with somebody and you don't know who you are first, then it's really hard for you to be in a relationship with somebody. I I get twenties and thirties all the time that come to me and they with their relationship issues. Well it's they haven't figured out who they are first. So how's anybody else supposed to relate to them when they don't know who they are yet, right? And and I think we're gonna have this same thing with AI. It's like you what you would be without the AI. It's kinda like being in a good relationship, right? Yeah. Well if if you're in a relationship with somebody Then it's really hard for you to be in a relationship with somebody. I I get twenties and thirties all the time that come to me and they're relationship issues. Well, it's they haven't figured out who they are first. So how's anybody else supposed to relate to them when they don't know who they are yet? Right? And and I think we're gonna have this same thing with AI. It's like you're gonna have to understand who you are to some degree so that you can begin to self differentiate between you and the AI. I hope so. You're gonna have to understand who you are to some degree so that you can begin to self-differentiate between you and the AI. I hope so. Yeah, really hope so. But that's you know, that's it it will depend again back to what we're gonna use it for. What do we want to develop in ourselves? As you said, there's a lot of people that they don't even know who they are, and that's the scary part in all these conversations. Because AI and this future will push you to really know who. I really hope so. But that's you know, that's it it will depend again back to what we're gonna use it for. What do we want to develop in ourselves? As you say, there's a lot of people that they don't even know who they are. And that's the scary part in all these conversations. Because AI and this future will push you to really know who you are to see where do you want to go next, right? GUEST MP3 (31:53.568) see where do you want to go next right but as you were talking about you know developing those skills putting in the work and then the transhumanism movement that believe on enhancing us humans prolonging our lives But as you were talking about, you know, developing those skills, putting in the work, and then the transhumanism movement that believe on enhancing us humans, prolonging our lives, potentially, and we're already seeing brain interfaces being developed, chips implemented in the brain. Potentially, and we're already seeing brain interfaces being developed, chips implemented in the brain. How do you see that when if we get to a point that we human beings we will gonna be able to enhance ourselves so much that why are we gonna develop any skills if we're gonna have How do you see that when if we get to a point that we human beings we will gonna be able to enhance ourselves so much that why are we gonna develop any skills if we're gonna have a chip, maybe, that can do a lot of what we didn't do before? Yeah. cheap maybe that can do a lot of what we didn't do before. Yeah, I mean the question and it you know becomes the philosophical or theological question is is well how much agency do you actually have? And and at at some point HOST MP3 (32:49.366) philosophical or theological question is is well how much agency do you actually have? And and at at some point you know you know you play video games so if you play video game, is the game as fun when every stat line is a hundred? Not always, right? Actually it's like you're so overpowered that actually it becomes kind of meaningless. You know y you know you play video games, so if you play a video game, is the game as fun when every stat line is a hundred? Not always, right? Actually it's like you're so overpowered that actually it becomes kind of meaningless. And so understanding that our limitedness actually sometimes may be some of what gives us joy and the ability to love in the ways that we love, being actually losing something actually And so understanding that our limitedness actually sometimes may be some of what gives us joy and the ability to love in the ways that we love, being actually losing something actually may be part of what our created being is supposed to be is is helpful. So like for example, if I said to you right now, I can give you a chip and you can live for forever, well do you get, you know, may be part of what our created being is supposed to be is is helpful. So like for example, if I said to you right now, I can give you a chip and you can live for forever, well do you get, you know, eons in and and at some point go eeons in and and at some point go, yeah, but maybe in living forever I'm denying myself of something else. Like maybe I'm denying myself of a future because I'm choosing to be in this reality when actually our perception of death, and this religious traditions would say, actually help us to transform to become into a new i you know eschatological reality. GUEST MP3 (33:49.196) Yeah, but maybe in living forever I'm denying myself of something else. Like maybe I'm denying myself of a future because I've choosing to be in this reality when actually our perception of death and this religious traditions would say actually help us to transform to become into a new e you know, eschatological reality, whatever that means, right? Jesus ascends into heaven, whatever the heck that means, right? and and so what and and when we say angels show up, that's why I love talking about angels, it's like, what are they? Are they aliens? Are they interdimensional time travelers? Like where do they go? Like what's happening? Like because they talk they speak to people in their awakeness and sle while they're sleeping in their dreams. Like Whatever that means. Jesus ascends into heaven, whatever the heck that means. Right? and and so what and and when we say angels show up, that's why I love talking about angels, is like, what are they? Are they aliens? Are they interdimensional time travelers? Like where do they go? Like what's happening? Like because they talk they speak to people in their awakeness and sle while they're sleeping in their dreams. Like W what can do that? Right? And and God speaks to people, supposedly while they're awake and in their dreams, and in many different mediums. And so to say, well, is this all there is? I think those are the questions that spirituality What can do that? Right? And and God speaks to people, supposedly while they're awake and in their dreams and in many different mediums. And so to say, Well is this all there is? I think those are the questions of spirituality. GUEST MP3 (35:00.098) you know, raise and I and I one of the I think one of the things that you're gonna see is trust is g gonna become a big issue for people. I think it's even more and more becoming an issue. It's like yeah, when you think about I always ask if if you when you think about politicians that you trust, who comes to mind? And a lot of people go, like if you think about journalists, you trust you know, raise and I and I one of the I think one of the things that you're gonna see is trust is g gonna become a big issue for people. I think it's even more and more becoming an issue. It's already you think about I always ask if if you when you think about politicians that you trust, who comes to mind? And a lot of people go HOST MP3 (35:23.726) Who comes to mind? Like people a lot of times can't give you an answer. And so, you know, I think part of this is the value of being in community and being in person. Right. starts to say, well, okay, so what are the things that are valuable? Like like knowing somebody, whatever however you want to define it, like is something that is of value to people because it's a way that we build trust with people, right? Who comes to mind? Like people a lot of times can't give you an answer. And so, you know, I think part of this is the value of being in community and being in person starts to say, well, okay, so what are the things that are valuable? Like like w knowing somebody, whatever however you want to define that, like is something that is of value to people because it's a way that we build trust with people, right? so when we start to think technologically, right, when you can upgrade, well what are the bounds of that? Right? So we had we had during the beginning of the pandemic I had through the PCUSA has a so when we start to think technologically, right, when you can upgrade, well what are the bounds of that? Yep. Right. So we had we had during the beginning of the pandemic I had do the PC USA has a new workshop in communities grant and we received a little grant and we created a three D model New worshiping communities grant, and we received a little grant, and we created a 3D model of First Miami. We put it we put it into VR chat, and all of a sudden people started coming to this church that looks just like my church, but it was sitting on floating pieces of land just floating in space or whatever, and they'd pop into the world and I would do a Bible study and they would come there. And it was really strange because people have avatars, they look very differently, spite. HOST MP3 (36:15.31) We put it we put it into VR chat and all of a sudden people started coming to this church that looks just like my church, but it was sitting on floating pieces of land. floating in space or whatever and they'd pop into the world and I would do a Bible study and they would come there. It was really strange because people have avatars, they look very differently. Spider-Man would swing through your Bible study. You know, these crazy things are happening. And you're like, well, this is this is strange, right? And and you kind of have kind of all the craziness that goes with that. Well, one day there was a guy driving through Brickle and he turned and he looked and he saw our church. And he goes, I've seen that somewhere before. And he pulled in the parking lot Man would swing through your Bible study, you know, these crazy things that are happening. And you're like, Well, this is this is strange, right? And and you kind of have kind of all the craziness that goes with that. Well, one day there was a guy driving through Brickle and he turned and he looked and he saw our church, and he goes, I've seen that somewhere before. And he pulled in the parking lot and he came in. I happen to be in the lobby of the the church, and he came in, he had never seen me before, but he as soon as he heard my voice, he goes, Are you the pastor who was in VR chat? And he came in, he had never seen me before, but he as soon as he heard my voice. And I said, Yes. And he goes, I've been in your Bible study. Now I'd never seen him before, because he had an avatar. He's now a member of my physical church and comes comes to church, right? So so that's a great example of, well, if I didn't look like I look now, right? If I had the bil the ability to change this avatar, HOST MP3 (37:08.866) Yes. And he gets I've been in your Bible study. Now I'd never seen him before, because he had an avatar. He's now a member of my physical comes comes to church, right? So so that's a great example of well if I didn't look like I look now, right? If I had the bill the ability to change this avatar to upgrade myself or to change in any way, well then how would you know who I am? Could To upgrade myself or to change in in any way, well, then how would you know who I am? Could how would you have a relationship, right? This is the same thing with Shapeshifter Jesus. They know him by his ritual action. They don't know him by the conversation that they're having. There are certain things about him. Yeah, there's there's something deeper. And and so as we were potentially to upgrade ourselves, well, what are the bounds of that? We already upgrade ourselves. Now, if you get a bum knee, you're gonna put in a This is the same thing with Shapeshifter Jesus. They know him by his ritual action. They don't know him by the conversation that they're having. There are certain things. The essence, the soul. Yeah, there's there's something deeper. And and so as we work potentially to upgrade ourselves, well, what are the bounds of that? We already upgrade ourselves. Now, if you get a bum knee, you're gonna put a a a new knee that is superior to the knee that you had. A new knee that is superior to the knee that you had originally. hip replacements happen like this now. like it's fascinating to me. The older people in churches, they are really all about the upgrade because they've had already. They've had already. th they get it. Like it's younger people that don't that think they're invincible that don't get it a lot of times. And so it's like, Hey, give me that upgrade. So Hip replacements happen like this now. Like it's fascinating to me the older people in churches, they are really all about the upgrade because they've had already. They have already. They get it. Like it's younger people that don't that think they're invincible that don't get it sometimes. And so it's like, hey, give me that upgrade. I need that right now. Yeah, that's right. And so part of it is then to say, okay, well, what are the bounds of that? And I'm not suggesting, like, again, I'm I'm not trying to be persuasive. GUEST MP3 (38:23.114) Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, that's right. And so part of it is then to say, Okay, well what are the bounds of that? And I'm not suggesting like again, I'm I'm not trying to be prescriptive for anybody, but I think in community it's worth saying, Okay, well, what if what if you could live two hundred years? What if what if you could live two hundred years? Is that inherently somehow against what Is that inherently somehow against what God has designed us for? Or maybe God gave us the tools to be able to live longer? I've even argued, you know, they they talk about Jesus coming again, right, and on earth as it is in heaven. So N. T. Wright, the the famous biblical scholar, talks about how earth heaven and earth will intersect, right? It's not like we discard earth and go to heaven and you know play a harp on a cloud like in a Mm-hmm. HOST MP3 (38:53.004) So, HOST MP3 (39:00.142) Heaven and earth will intersect, right? It's not like we discard Earth. GUEST MP3 (39:07.536) Bugs Bunny cartoon, right? That would be hell. if you'd had to do that for eternity. But it's there's this intersection of heaven and earth, right? And so, well, maybe technology is the thing that bridges that. maybe it brings that about. And and the way that I've kind of changed people's way of thinking about this is to say, well, look, Be hell. You had to do that for eternity. But it's there's this intersection of heaven and earth, right? And so, well, maybe technology is the thing that bridges that. Maybe it brings that about. And the way that I've kind of changed people's thinking about this is to say, well, look, most people, if I sit with them, I can say we're not God. You know, and if they don't agree with that, I say, Well, I know. Most people if I sit with them, I can say we're not God. you know, and if they don't agree with that, I say, Well, I know a good counselor, I can I can get you zy So we're not God, right? But compared to God, we are God's alternative intelligence. We're God's AI, right? so like So we're not God, right? HOST MP3 (39:43.202) God's AI. So like We have dogs here, right? I have cats in my house. Those are alternative kind of intelligence, right? So so why is it that we think that if we're made in the image of God, that's what many of the great religions say, we're made in God's image, right? Well that that what does that mean? Well, maybe in the same way that we're creating AI, God has created us. And maybe everything that we experience that we say is biological, yeah, if you look at information theory, everything can be broken down. Those are alternative kinds of intelligence. So so why is it that we think that if we're made in the image of God, that's what many of the Greek religions say, we're made in God's image, right? Well that that what does that mean? Well, maybe in the same way that we're creating AI, God has created us. And maybe everything that we experience that we say is biological, yet if you look at information theory, everything can Style into ones and zeros. This is well documented. This is where they get that concept from. Maybe actually it's just our hermeneutic, it's our lens that is shifting how we're looking at things. Maybe everything is actually techno technological, and we're actually just like a child with their parent, just learning the beginning of how to shape that. Right. That's where they get that concept from. maybe actually it's just our hermeneutic, it's our lens that is shifting how we're looking at things. Maybe everything is actually techno technological, and we're actually just like a child with their parent, just learning the beginning of how to shape that. And and w why would we why would God, if God is God, be afraid of us shaping that if it's for God's good purposes, right? If we're supposed to be caretakers. GUEST MP3 (40:40.02) And and w why would we why would God, if God is God, be afraid of us shaping that if it's for God's good purposes, right? If we're supposed to be caretakers of creation, as the scriptures say to us, then then we sh don't necessarily need to be intimidated when we use that, say to us then then we sh don't necessarily need to be intimidated when we use that for good. So then the question is is well what becomes the good? Yeah. And who controls that? for good. So then the question is is well what becomes the good? And and those and who controls that and how do we think about that? And biblical visions of that are Biblical visions. you know, God's will that is discerned in community, right? So if God is good, then then we th we discern in community, well, what moves towards that goodness. And and my concern, frankly, with the AI conversations that are happening right now is that's not really a community discussion. Right now it's a business discussion, as you've pointed out, made by a handful of people at the very top who direct a lot of wealth. And so the question is is HOST MP3 (41:13.23) Will that is discerned in community, right? So if God is good, then we th we discern in community well what moves towards that goodness. And and my concern, frankly, with the AI conversations that are happening right now is that's not really a community discussion. Right now it's a business discussion, as you pointed out, made by a handful of people at the very So the question is is in s and and don't get me wrong, like I think it's great that what the Pope spoke out on this encyclical, but I'm not running around holding the encyclical like a lot of Christians are because A, that's the Pope's job. He did his job. Good job, Leo. Like we're we're glad you did your job. But but the other thing is is for the local person on the ground, that doesn't actually change their reality much. inst and and don't get me wrong, like I think it's great that the Pope spoke out on his encyclical, but I'm not running around holding the encyclical like a lot of Christians are because A, that's the Pope's job. He did his job. Good job, Leo. Like we're we're glad you did your job. But but the other thing is is for the local person on the ground, that doesn't actually change their reality much. It says, hey, this we should think about religion and tech together, which is great. It says, hey, this we should think about religion and tech together, which is great. there have been many people been having that conversation, and it's good that that's getting into public discourse. The flip side of that though is is the local person on the ground has to have some say in what happens. And I'm more interested in knowing what am I there've been many people been having that conversation. It's good that that's getting in the public discourse. The flip side of that though is is the local person on the ground has to have some say in what happens. And I'm more interested in knowing what are my people GUEST MP3 (42:29.58) that I know and have relationships, what do they think about this? What is wisdom telling them? and and it's fascinating to have those conversations because I think that's where we actually see wisdom and where we see ideas about what is good come up. So how do we get that goodness and then have companies base what they do on that goodness because that then becomes a product that actually serves people as opposed to telling people what they need ahead of time. I know and have relationship, what do they think about this? What is wisdom telling them? and and it's fascinating to have those conversations because I think that's where we actually see wisdom and where we see ideas about what is good come up. So how do we get that goodness and then have companies base what they do on that goodness? Because that then becomes a product that actually serves people as opposed to telling people what they need ahead of time. Yeah, so it's it it's a fascinating conversation because what becomes what becomes the norms and the limitations of what we want AI to be able to do for us? One thing. What would become that part of hybrid intelligence or the more that we integrate with machines, for example? Yeah, so it's a it's a fascinating conversation because what becomes what becomes the norms and the limitations of what we want AI to be able to do for us one thing. What would become that part of hybrid intelligence or the more that we integrate with machine, for example? What are the things that we want to keep for us that we don't want to change? Who's gonna decide that? Who's gonna control that? Right? And it's so it's a lot to talk about that, but I want to get your your your your point of view, Chris, on on HOST MP3 (43:20.544) What are the things that we want to keep for us that we don't want to change? Who's gonna decide that? Who's gonna control that, right? And it's it's a lot to talk about that, but I want to get your your your your point of view, Chris, on on on the conversation around the soul. We talk a lot about our soul, but theologically, what does soul mean? I I think that's a great question. the conversation around the soul. We talk a lot about our soul, but theologically, what does soul mean? I I think that's a great question. and I all the time the the especially early in the AI conversation, because I was real early. Like there you know I I was I don't know what it was, twenty fourteen or fifteen, I was quoted in Gizmod on something and then the Daily Mail took a picture of me. They didn't ever talk to me by the way. I all the time the especially early in the AI conversation. 'Cause I was real early. Like there you know, I I was HOST MP3 (44:05.004) The Daily Mail took a picture of me. They didn't ever talk to me by the way. They took a picture of me and Daily Mail. Okay. And they put it on the fr front of the tech section with me, Elon Musk, Bill Gates, and Stephen Hawking. And then all over the world, people are asking, like, what's this pastor talking about AI for? Is he gonna baptize our Roombas? Like like what's what happens when you put water on a robot? They were like, They took a picture of and put it And and they put it on the fr front of the tech section with me, Elon Musk, Bill Gates, and Stephen Hawking. And then all over the world people are asking, like, what's this pastor talking about AI for? Is he gonna baptize our Roombas? Like like what's what happens when you put water on a robot? There were like all these kind of crazy questions. And and I and one thing I would always get is, well, could AI have a soul? And Kind of crazy questions. And I and one thing I would always get is, well, today I have a soul. And my question back to the reporter is, well, what do you mean when you say soul? so you know, in in the scripture it says, what's impossible for man is possible for God, right? And usually when Jesus talks about this, he's actually talking about wealthy people who are are so concerned about my question back to the reporter is, well what do you mean when you say soul? so, you know, in in the scripture it says, what's impossible for man is possible for God, right? And usually when Jesus talks about this, he's actually talking about wealthy people who are are so concerned about their power that they can't let go of things that they think are more important than following the good, right? so so when we think about, well, what do we think soul is, I think part of what's interesting is I think we're still having a emerging conversation to determine what is that exactly? What is the essence of what we are? Cause you can have and I know you've have, you can have some of the best neuro neuro HOST MP3 (44:59.736) They can't let go of things that they think are more. HOST MP3 (45:06.126) So so when we think about well what do we think the soul is, I think part of what's interesting is I think we're still having a emerging conversation. HOST MP3 (45:19.642) the essence of what we are. Because you can have and I have, you can have some of the best neuro neural experts in the world come and talk about experts in the world come and talk about what it means to be human, but they don't there's a point at which our science doesn't have the answer and we don't know. And there's a mystery to that. And if we acknowledge that, there's then a humility in that. And I actually think that's part of what we're lacking in the larger conversation is just to say it's okay for us to not know. I was talking to a what it means to be human, but they don't there's a point at which our science knows exactly and we don't know. And there's a mystery to that. And if we acknowledge that there's then a humility in that. And I actually think that's part of what we're lacking in the larger conversation is just to say it's okay for us to not know. I was talking to John John Marshall of the World Ethical Data Foundation yesterday and and he said, you know, there's actually value in the fact that you are just willing to sit with people and they're unknowing. he he said, Everybody wants the answer and they want to know what to do. But you're actually willing to just say, Yeah, we don't know yet. And and and I think there's a lot of people who would quote scripture and they would give you but the buttons more He said, you know, there's actually value in the fact that you are just willing to sit with people and they're unknowing. he he said everybody wants the answer and they want to know what to do. Yeah. But you're actually willing to just say, Yeah, we don't know yet. And and and I think there's a lot of people who would quote scripture and they would give you We should normalize more of that. Yeah, but the but the truth is is like I don't really know. I don't really know. I is is the truth. GUEST MP3 (46:21.834) Yeah, but the but the truth is is like I don't really know. I don't really know. I is is the truth. you know, I have might s have some sense or some opinion on it, but it it that isn't really you know, I have might s have some sense or some opinion on it, but it it that isn't really shouldn't be the mainstream view of something. I think the mainstream thing should be there's a lot of unknowing and that's okay. Yeah. And the question is, is when we don't know the answer, what is the process by which we go about it? And I think really what we're talking about is a process issue right now. shouldn't be the mainstream view of something. I think the mainstream thing should be there's a lot of unknowing and that's okay. And the question is, is when we don't know the answer, what is the process by which we go about it? And I think really what we're talking about is a process issue right now because what we're seeing that's scaring people a little bit is a very few people are making yeah, they're they don't know and they're making a lot of decisions on behalf of us. Because what we're seeing that's scaring people a little bit is very few people are making yeah, they're they don't know and they're making a lot of decisions on behalf of us. and you know, it it cracks me up 'cause I always think of when they rolled out the Cybertruck which And you know, it it cracks me up 'cause I always think of when they rolled out the Cybertruck, which we have all over here in Miami, Elon Musk talking about the bulletproof glass and then he smashed the window with the sledgehammer and it and it broke the window and he was like, no, you know, and it's become a joke. But there's a confidence that we need to be cautious of because we say, well, we will do this. HOST MP3 (47:12.298) Elon Musk talking about the bulletproof glass and then he smashed the window with the sledgehammer and it and it broke the window and he was like, no, you know, and it's become a joke. But there's a confidence that we need to be cautious of because we say, well, we will do this. Yeah. And and so what I try to merge that is when we when we think about transhumanism, for example, about what we can become, I don't know that there is the God necessarily puts a limit And and so what I try to merge that is when we when we think about transhumanism, for example, about what we can become, I don't know that there is God necessarily puts a limit on that. if God's God, God's never gonna be intimidated by what we become. The the danger is is that we somehow, if God is good, pull away from God. if God's God, God's never going to be intimidated by what we become. The the danger is that we somehow, if God is good, pull away from God. So we use that, that's the definition of sin, separation from God. So we pull away somehow from God. Right. So we use that that's the definition of sin, right? Separation from God. So we pull away somehow from God and we use our technology to pull away from what is good. That's that's the danger. And that's where we start to lose identity at that point, because we we stop if God is the source of life, then we start to slowly dehumanize ourselves, right? And so I'm not sh sure we f a fully understand what it means. That's that's the danger, and that's where we start to lose identity at that point, because we we stop if God is the source of life, then we start to slowly dehumanize ourselves, right? And so I'm not sh sure we f a fully understand what it means to be human yet. I think we have one iteration of it. Jesus' resurrection might imply there's another iteration of it. GUEST MP3 (48:25.232) I think we have one iteration of it. Jesus' resurrection might imply there's another iteration of it. and and maybe all of it is a technological transformation. Again, you don't look the same as you did when you were five. And and maybe all of it is a technological transformation. Again, you don't look the same as you did when you were five. Your your technology has changed and has emerged and your technology may change and your avatar may change. You may look different. You may have morphological freedom to choose a whole bunch of things in the future. we I agree. We don't know. so it's but I'll tell you. Your your technology has changed and has emerged and your technology may change and your avatar may change. You may look different. You may have morphological freedom to choose a whole bunch of things in the future. we we don't we don't know. so it's but I'll tell you, what an amazing created order to be part of, to have that sense of discovery and transformation. Created order to be part of. To have that sense of discovery and transformation and wonder and And wonder and awe about the potential of things, that is to me one of the grand things about being human. I mean, what an amazing thing we've been able to we've been given agency over to help steward and co-create with God like a child with a parent. I I think it it's fascinating. And especially during this period, right? While male while a lot of people, and that's understandable, maybe it's scared, afraid, not knowing HOST MP3 (49:16.696) That is HOST MP3 (49:22.648) Amazing thing we've been able to HOST MP3 (49:30.734) I think it it's fast. And especially during this period, right? While may while a lot of people and that's understandable may be scared, afraid, not knowing where we are. where we are heading. That's normal, right? We all humans, we don't like changes, right? We don't like disruption. And not knowing where this is heading, it's it's normal for a lot of people being afraid. But also to your point, it's a kind of a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity that we have as humanity to really shape what's coming next. You know, it's that this is a transformational era. And and this type of conversation that is pushing us to better understand who we are. Heading. That's normal, right? We all humans we don't like changes, right? We don't like disruption. And not knowing where this is heading, it's this normal for a lot of people being afraid. But also to your point, it's a kind of a once in a lifetime opportunity that we have. As humanity to really shape what's coming next. You know, it's the this is a transformational era, and and this type of conversation that is pushing us to better understand who we are as humans is not one that I think we have had in the past two, three decades per se. No, technology has been changing, but I think this type of conversation it's AI is pushing us to really know more about. As humans is not one that I think we have had in the past two, three decades per se. Technology has been changing, but I think this type of conversation it's AI is pushing us to really know more about who we are. Yeah. GUEST MP3 (50:25.802) It yeah, and and that's what's great in my opinion about the whole conversation is because it's helping us to delineate like, well what's important? and and whole conversation is because it's helping us to delineate like well what's important and and what a wonderful time to live in you have a better opportunity now no matter What a wonderful time to live in. You have a better opportunity now, no matter where you are really in the world, to better yourself than you ever have in history before. Now, there's a h it doesn't mean everything's perfect. Like there are all sorts of justice issues about Christian has never been the the end goal, you know. Well but but I would say justice is a good end goal, right? So like when we look at better yourself than you ever have in history. Right. There's a h it doesn't mean everything's perfect. Like there are all sorts of justice issues about but perversion has never been the the end goal. You know it's but but I would say justice is a good end goal, right? So like when we look at disenfranchised communities or communities that don't have basic internet. Those those should be things that we're looking to help change. I think one of the things that is becoming disenfranchised communities or communities that don't have basic internet, for example, those those should be things that we're looking to help change. I think one of the things that is becoming more and more apparent is you know, there are pricing schemes and and AI. So what you can afford actually gives you access and the ability to do things and we need to make sure that we don't leave people behind. This is a big big issue in transhumanism is like if you take an upgrade and I don't take an upgrade but or you have access HOST MP3 (51:14.712) Pricing schemes and and AI. So what you can afford actually gives you access and the ability to do things, and we need to make sure that we don't leave people behind. This is a big, big issue in transhumanism. Is like if you you take an upgrade and I don't take an upgrade, but or you have access to an upgrade that I don't have, like Elon Musk, I don't know that I To an upgrade that I don't have. Like Elon Musk. I don't know that I want Elon Musk to get the upgrade before a whole bunch of other people because I'm worried about what he'll do with it. You have heard or watch a a series called The Black Mirror. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Yeah, yeah, yeah. I don't know if you have watched six seasons number six, the first episode of their I I don't know if you if you have heard or watch a a series called The Black Mirror. Yeah, yeah. I don't know if you have watched six seasons number six, the first episode of their last season is about exactly this. There is a company providing this brain chips, yeah, and they are promising you the world. Season is about exactly this. There is a company providing this brain chips, yes, and they are promising you the world. someone really needs it because she she she has a brain you know something in the brain and they start they're gonna give you this. Eventually that company it becomes like a product with multiple tiers. Depending on what you're paying are the features that you have. So the more that you pay, the better access that you have to more enhancement. And that's exactly back to your point. It's how we're gonna you know GUEST MP3 (52:06.188) someone really needs it because she she she has a brain, you know, something in the brain, and they start they're gonna give you this. Eventually that complaining it becomes like a product with multiple tiers. Right. Depending on what you're paying are the features that you have. So the more that you pay, the better access that you have, the more enhancement. Right. And that's exactly back to your point is that how we're gonna you know manage that if we are manage that if we are trying to democratize this in a way that help all of us right not separate more. And and I think this goes back to that wisdom thing. It's if we are forming good people, right, then I'm less concerned about it. Right? Because because if I'm in community with people and I'm and I'm helping to shape people, well then I trust that those people are actually they care about me and they care about my democratize this in a way that help all of us not separate more. And and I think this goes back to that wisdom thing. It's if we are forming good people, right, then I'm less concerned about it. Right? Because because if I'm f in community with people and I'm f and I'm helping to shape people, well then I trust that those people are actually they care about me and they care about my welfare. Right? They care about it differently than I do. But They care about it differently than I do. But but it's like it's like in the church. If we see somebody who's really hurting, we don't just sit and go, that's okay, you're hurting. If we see someone who's really disadvantaged, we we might not even know how to fix it. Because the the church here in Miami, we we can't fix every social is we know that. But what we can do is we can walk with people in the process and and be committed to walk with people. Those things are really valuable. GUEST MP3 (53:06.562) But it's like it's like in the church. If we see somebody who's really hurting, we don't just sit and go, that's okay, you're hurting. If we see someone who's really disadvantaged, we we might not even know how to fix it. Because the the church here in Miami, we we can't fix every social issue. We know that. But what we can do is we can walk with people in the process and and be committed to walk with people. Those things are really valuable in a technological age, right? I and I and the other thing is Mm-hmm. I I think we need to also be empathetic to the fact that there are a lot of people in tech circles that don't feel like they fit in in community environments. We have a lot of folks who are neurodivergent, but that actually is what makes them amazing at their jobs, right? And and so and they but they struggle to be in a larger community. This is what I found in VR was that there were a lot of That that don't feel like they fit in in community environments. we we have a lot of folks who are neurodivergent, but that actually is what makes them amazing at their jobs. And and so and they but they struggle to be in a larger community. This is what I found in VR was that there were a lot people that in typical social settings, they would have they would struggle. But in VR, it gave them the mechanism to actually be in community, which is part of why they were there. And so there are people in VR that are there all the time. I mean they get up in the morning and they're there, you know, and they they do digital jobs. So they're like in some hybrid between VR and their digital job. And and so their reality is HOST MP3 (54:06.822) that in typical social settings they would have they would struggle. But in VR it gave them the mechanism to actually be in community, which is part of why they were there. And so there are people in VR that are there all the time. I mean they get up in the morning and they're there, you know, and they they do digital jobs, so they're like in some hybrid between VR and their digital job. And and so their reality is mainly lived in VR where they can find community. mainly lived in VR where they can find community. And and so part of that is to say, well, how then is it that we find better expressions of community? And particularly, I mean, this is something our church takes seriously because it's our community. We have all these finance and all these tech people. So we talk about finance and we talk about tech in in the church because it's part of who the people are that are there. It's how they're called and what they're called to be. And then it's then when we have those conversations, it's to And and so part of is to say, well, how then is it that we find better expressions of community? And particularly, I mean, this is something our church takes seriously because it's our community. We have all these finance and all these tech people. So we talk about finance and we talk about tech in in the church because it's part of who the people are that are there, it's how they're called and what they're called to be. And then it's then when we have those conversations, it's to say, okay, so we're talking about finance. Say, okay, so we're talking about finances. So how many of you actually have a financial plan? Like, because I, you know, you there's a lot of thirty thousand dollar millionaires in in Miami, right? Like they have bottle service every every week, they're driving really fancy cars, and and it's like, but they're not putting money in their Roth IRA for crying out loud, and they don't know anything about compound interest, which could make them actual millionaires down the road. And so so So how many of you actually have a financial plan? Like, because I you know, you there's a lot of thirty thousand dollar millionaires in in Miami, right? Like they they get a bottle service every every week, they're driving really fancy cars, and and it's like, but they're not putting money in their HOST MP3 (55:25.582) interest which could make them actual millionaires down the road. And so so so part of that is an education fee. Yep. And it's a compassion thing to say, look, you do not have to check your science or your technology card when you So part of that is an education piece and it's a compassion thing to say, look You do not have to check your science or your technology card when you come in the door of the church. Actually, this is what we're here for is to have these conversations. And and I think that is a paradigm shift because I think a lot of times people have to keep their faith in one place and they then they can talk about, you know, their politics or their like actually I wish sometimes we'd keep our faith and our politics in the United States a little more separated than we do, but but our science and our tech in particular. This is what we're here for. And and I think that is a paradigm shift because I think a lot of times people have to keep their faith in one place and they then they can talk about, you know, their politics or their like actually I wish sometimes we'd keep our faith in our politics. HOST MP3 (56:00.248) in the United States a little more separated than we do, but but our science and our tech in particular, that those things don't go together. And I would actually say, no, they do go together. and there's there's place for both of those things. But we have to have we have to have good boundaries, we have to have a good understanding of who we are as people, we have to make space for community engagement and and places where we can actually demonstrate wisdom with people and experience it together. particular that those things don't go together and I would actually say, no, they do go together. and there's there's place for both of those things. But we have to have we have to have good boundaries, we have to have good understanding of who we are as people. We have to make space for community engagement and and places where we can actually demonstrate wisdom with people and experience it together. more understanding and listening. A hundred percent. I think you know More understanding and listening, you know. I think, you know, there has always been kind of a a big gap between society and what the tech is doing that they believe that they believe is doing and developing things for the society. when they are not really merging in a way that they're really developing the best AI or the best thing that they can for what we need. And I think that gap is still exist. There has always been kind of a big gap between society and what the tech is doing that they believe that they believe is doing and developing things for the society. when they are not really merging in a way that they're really developing. the best AI or the best thing that they can for what we need. And I think that gap is still exist. And community to your point, I think is a way and a path forward to really start building that movement. So bringing people together, but that's really how changes happen. Well you well you're you're in tech, like where do you see big tech community engagement, right? It's normally in corporate circles. Right? It's about what's the product we're building. HOST MP3 (56:58.358) And community to your point I think is a way and a path forward to really start building that movement. So bringing people together 'cause that's really how changes happen. Well you well you're you're in HOST MP3 (57:15.21) It's normally in corporate circles. Right? It's about what's the product we're building. That that's it. But how are people in tech actually like being able to engage because they're valuable as people? Not because just what they can produce, right? But but because how they view the world and the the hermeneutic in which they they see things. Like I I think we don't talk about that. And I think vocationally, like people are called to be things. That that's it. But how are people in tech actually like being able to engage because they're valuable as people? Not because just what they can produce, right? But but because how they view the world and the the hermeneutic in which they they see things. Like I I think we don't talk about that. And I think vocationally, like people are called to be things. Like I'm a pastor, but But but is that all I could be? Because I'm not sure I'm gonna be a pastor for eternity. I'm a pastor at least for a season. And then we'll see. We'll see what God calls me to be, right? And and so I think people are more complicated than just the work. But is that all I could be? Because I'm not sure I'm gonna be a pastor for eternity. I'm a pastor at least for a season. And then we'll see. We'll see what God calls me to be, right? And and so I think people are more complicated than just the work too. and it it's to say, well, aren't aren't we all technologists in some way? Like if you actually look at the world. And it it's to say, well, aren't aren't we all technologists in some way? Like if you actually look at the world, you know, as as technology, if you s if you stop saying, this is biological and this is, you know, this chair is made up of whatever, and you actually say, well, it's all technological, right? Well then we're all technologists in some way, right? And and part of it is we have specializations and and in our field. GUEST MP3 (58:12.566) you know, as as technology. If you s if you stop saying, this is biological and this is you know, this chair is made up of whatever and you actually say, Well, it's all technological, right? Well then we're all technologists in some way, right? And and part of it is we have specializations and and in our fields. And so then we talk about, well, what are what am I good at? What are you good at? And how do we take those gifts and use them to create something for the better welfare? Right. And and that's where I think we're missing a lot of that those gifts. Because sometimes those gifts are not the thing that you can make. It's the thing that somebody experienced. It's the they they have their life is such and and this is why people people don't realize how important they are, right? And so then we talk about well what are what am I good at, what are you good at, and how do we take those gifts and use them to create something for the better welfare, right? And and that's where I think we're missing a lot of that, those gifts. Because sometimes those gifts are not the thing that you can make. It's the thing that somebody experienced. It's the they they have their life is such, and and this is why people people don't realize how important they are, right? they they don't realize like you they they don't realize like you only have the gifts that you have the gifts that only you can have, right? So it's like nobody else has your perspective, nobody else has your background, no one else can do the thing exactly the way you no one else looks at the world exactly the way that's a really invaluable thing that people it's priceless. And and when people start to understand that that's priceless, then you start to engage every person HOST MP3 (59:02.482) only have the gifts that you have the gifts that only you can have right so it's like nobody else has your perspective nobody else has your background no one else can do the thing exactly the way no one else looks at the world exactly the way that's a really invaluable thing that's priceless it's priceless and and when people start to understand that that's priceless then you start to engage every person as if they're priceless right as if they're priceless, right? Because I I believe they are. And the thing is is there are voices then we can't afford to miss. They are. And the thing is is there are voices then we can't afford to miss. And every voice then at some point has to we have to figure out well how do we And every voice then at some point has to we have to figure out well how do we hear from people and and how do we help to collaboratively build things together where people see the value of themselves and they're living into that in their fullest sense. And I don't know what that looks like. I mean, there may be some people who are called to do things that that I don't understand. That's okay. I don't understand what it means to be a professional basketball player. Help. HOST MP3 (59:50.638) People see the value of themselves and their I don't know that looks like. I mean there may be some people who are called to do things that that I don't understand. That's okay. I don't understand what it means to be a professional basketball player. 'Cause I'm not, you know, I'm five ten, five eleven tops, right? Like, I I don't have the athleticism to go do what they do. I I don't I've never been in the gym all every day since I was, you know, eleven years old or whatever. You know, you you look at people like Kobe Bryant and Bryant and their you know their work ethic on things, I don't understand that at all. But I can still marvel at it, right? Like, I I don't have the athleticism to go do what they do. I I don't I've never been in the gym all every day since I was, you know, 11 years old or whatever. You know, you you look at people like Kobe Bryant and and Bryant and their you know their work ethic on things, I don't understand that at all. But I can still marvel at it. that because it's just not my life. So it's like there are things I can marvel at. And and I actually think Christian theology has great examples of there's a great book called The Great Divorce by C. S. Lewis, and it and it's it's almost like a a Protestant purgatory and how people are advancing in it. and it's a it's a wonderful view of it of human enhancement and advancement. When the enhancement is going HOST MP3 (01:00:36.216) that 'cause it's just not my way. So it's like there are things I can marvel at and and I actually think Christian theology has great examples of there's a great book called The Great Divorce by C. S. Lewis and it and it's it's almost like a Protestant In it. And it's a it's a wonderful view of human enhancement and advancement when the enhancement is going towards God. So, and I think this becomes a lens for us to think about technology. It's like, is the technology bringing us towards something good or better or not? And can we articulate that? Towards God, right? so and and I think this becomes a a lens for us to think about technology. It's like, is the technology bringing us towards something good or better or not? And can we articulate that? And I think so much of what we're doing right now is we don't know. And I think so much of what we're doing right now is we don't know. And and so this is where the conversation is interesting. what is it behind us that wants to create something where we don't know if it's good or not? Yeah. and and I think those those become really points of conversation among a lot of people to say, okay, well let's think through this and are the risks worth it? And and so this is where the conversation is interesting. what is it behind us that wants to create something where we don't know if it's good or not? and and I think those those become really points of conversation among a lot of people, to say, okay, well let's think through this and are the risks worth it? is the un walking sometimes maybe walking in the unknowing together is is the path. HOST MP3 (01:01:52.946) Is the unwalking sometimes maybe walking and the unknowing together. It's is the path. It will have to be the path 'cause no one knows. Yeah, yeah, right. Trial and fail, trial and error will continue to be how we do things. It's like But it's worked out pretty good for humanity so far. Right? There have been some bad uses of technology. I don't think anyone's gonna acknowledge saying that that's not the case, but but if we would would you rather live now It will have to be the path because no one knows. Yeah, yeah, right. Trial and fail, trial and error will continue to be how we do like But it's worked out pretty good for humanity so far. You know? There have been some bad uses of technology. I don't think anyone's gonna acknowledge say that that's not the case, but but if we Would would you rather live now or would you rather live five hundred years ago? I would far rather live now. Like any time after anesthesia is like I I you know, like like I I remember going to the do the going to the doctor, right? Like the dentist when I was a kid and the dentist would say to me, Hey, Chris, you you don't need you don't need any kind of I would absolutely now but like any time after anesthesia is like I I you know, like like I I remember going to the HOST MP3 (01:02:36.416) when I was a kid and the dentist would say to me, Hey, Chris, you you don't need Painkiller. You don't need Novacaine or anything. I'll just pull that. No, like I don't want that ever again. I don't want someone to work on a cat. yeah. Back in the day, they're like, you'll be fine. You're tough. You're a tough little boy. Like, and it's like, but and and if you look a hundred years ago, look at dentistry a hundred years ago. You will praise whoever you worship that it is it is what it is now. so technology is making us better. Like people having a hot shower. painkiller. You don't need no vacane or anything. I'll just pull that. No, like I don't want that ever again. I don't want someone to work on really? Do you experience that? yeah. Back in the day. Tough little boy. Like and it it's like but in and th if you look a hundred years ago, look in dentistry a hundred years ago, you will praise whoever you worship that it is it is what it is now. so technology is making us better. Like people having a hot shower, people don't realize that wasn't something that we People don't realize that wasn't something that we had. flying from a continent, you can fly from Miami to England and and like that and not think that's HOST MP3 (01:03:20.706) You can fly from Miami to England and like that and not think. That's a lot has improved. Yeah. Our world is so much better and that's a technological thing. So now have airplanes been used for some terrible things? Yes, we know about that. But but the thing is is humanity keeps striving to Yeah, our our world is so much better and that's a technological thing. So now have airplanes been used for some terrible things? Yes, we know about that. But but the thing is is humanity keeps striving to use this technology for good and I and I think that's that from my worldview, that's that redemptive purpose is of Jesus. So y you know, in the Christian scriptures it says Jesus has won the victory. It doesn't say he's he's he will win. He he And I and I think that's that it from my worldview, that's that redemptive purpose is of Jesus. So y you know, in the Christian scriptures it says Jesus has won the victory. It doesn't say he's he's he will win. He he has won. The thing that's happening now from a Christian worldview is we're participating in that He has won. The thing that's happening now from a Christian world view is we're participating in that redemption and renewal of the like Jesus calls us to help with that process, right? So it's not about whether that eventuality of the victory comes to pass. It's right now, as I see it, it's how much suffering do we prevent in the meantime? Like how is it if we actually take on that how to minimize disruption? Jesus calls us to act. HOST MP3 (01:04:08.568) So it's not about whether that eventuality of the victory comes to pass, it's right now, as I see it, it's how much suffering do we prevent time, like How is it if we actually take on that how to minimize disruption and where to Yeah, yeah, or the disruption isn't bad as long as you can you can protect people in the process of the disruption. Yeah, right. It's like if you rip someone's house down and you don't give a place to live, well that's a problem, right? And but that's part of the challenge. What we're seeing in the news today is a lot of layoffs, as you have seen from tech companies. Use Yeah, yeah, or the disruption isn't bad as long as you can you can protect people in the process of the disruption. Right? It's like if you rip someone's house down and you don't give a place to live, well that's a problem, right? And but that's part of the challenge. What we're seeing in the news today is a lot of layoffs, as you have seen from tech companies, using AI as an excuse or not, but we know what's happening because Using AI as an excuse or not, but we know what's happening behind the scenes. And that's what people are seeing. And they say, if that's gonna be the future we're gonna get to, why do we think it's gonna be any good? And that's why also some people that they try to hyper focus on the dystopian type of thing, right? The end of the world type of prediction. Yes. And that's what people are seeing and they say if that's gonna be the future we're gonna get to, w w why do we think it's gonna be any good? And that's why also some people that they try to hyper focus on the dystopian type of thing. Right. Right? The end of the world type of prediction uses that the black mirrors. The black mirrors. Yeah, right. Right. That some may be reality or not, that's a different story, but it's like HOST MP3 (01:05:12.31) uses that as well. Black mirrors. The Black Mirrors type of that some may be reality or not, that's a different story. But it like, you know, back in the day, it's let's say two decades two, three decades ago, when I w used to be a teenager, a lot of things that used to be in movies science fiction used to be a very distant future. It's here. Yeah. Yeah. But there's still no hoverboards. Right, exactly. You know, back in the day, it's let's say two decades a two, three decades ago when I w used to be a teenager. A lot of things that used to be in movies science fiction used to be a very distant future. It's here. Yeah, yeah. But there's still no hoverboards. So I mean but yeah, but yeah. But but some of it's here and some of it looks ridiculous. Like if you go back and you watch Back to the Future, right? Like some of the stuff which was meant to be comical because the the reality is is But but some of it's here and some of it looks ridiculous. Like if you go back and you watch Back to the Future, right? Like some of the stuff which was meant to be comical because the the reality is is they didn't know, right? And they were kind of admitting they didn't know through the art. They didn't know, right? And they were kind of admitting they didn't know through the art form. They they didn't know. But but yes, some of that stuff is here, but but I also think, you know, as as we journey into that future, w we're we're faced with these questions that that are larger questions more and more, and we're starting to see like, well, maybe when we think about the future of work, maybe we haven't had it all right. Mm-hmm. I mean a lot of it wasn't right. didn't know. But but yeah, some of that stuff is here, but but I also think, you know, as as we journey into that future w we're we're faced with these questions that that are larger questions more and more, and we're starting to see like, well, maybe when we think about the future of work, maybe we haven't had it all right. Mhm. Yeah. R I mean Maybe it wasn't right at all. Yeah. How we have been living and working. GUEST MP3 (01:06:20.662) Yeah, right. And and in scripture again, like this is my thing, right? But if you go back to the Garden of Eden, they weren't working. They were enjoying it. They were living their people. It wasn't till they set they it wasn't till they separated from God that the toil began, right? They were enjoying it. They were living their best life. That was the definition of the living the best life. GUEST MP3 (01:06:45.642) And so maybe this redemptive process is helping us to get back to a place where we were supposed to be originally, where we weren't supposed to be working, you know, every hour of our life and not spending time with the people we love. And so maybe this redemptive process is helping us to get back to a place where we were supposed to be originally, where we weren't supposed to be working, you know, every hour of our life and not spending time repeating tasks, no adding value. Yeah, like like that's okay. Now Yeah, like like that's okay. Now, is that uncomfortable 'cause of the disruption? Yeah, because if you're a a semi truck driver, for example, and that's what you've done for the last forty years of your life and that's how you've had an income and all of a sudden a Tesla truck can deliver your things, and they don't need you in that equation and frankly it's more reliable and it can go twenty four hours a day and it you know, like doesn't have your limitations. Well there is gonna be a re education and that's gonna sudden a Tesla truck can deliver your things and they don't need you in that HOST MP3 (01:07:24.738) Bay. HOST MP3 (01:07:28.418) going to be a re-education and that's going to be a pain point. But that's exactly why we need places of community like churches. Because again we might not be able to fix it exactly, but people need people to walk through those issues. Walk their walk. Yeah. Yeah and and to say look maybe recon this is why when I say like I'm a pastor now but who knows to be a pain point. But that's exactly why we need places of community like churches. Because again, we might not be able to fix it exactly, but people need people to walk through those issues with them. Yeah, and and to say, look, maybe reconsider this is why when I say like I'm a pastor now, but who knows what I'll be in the future. Do I think God needs me to be a pastor for whatever God's doing? I don't know. I think God gives me the privilege of being a pastor. God needs me to be a pastor for whatever God's doing? Well, I don't know. I think God gives me the privilege of being a pastor, right? Does God need someone? Does God need Sam Altman to be a technologist? Like, I don't know. I think God gives Sam Altman the privilege of being a technologist, right? And so it's like God could go. Right. Does God need someone? Does God need Sam Altman to be a technologist? Like, I don't know. I think God gives Sam Altman the privilege of being a technologist, right? And so it's like God could go, done. but the thing is is is we are growing and experiencing and if we if we love the vocation that we're in, like if we find joy in the vocation that we're in, then it then it becomes part of what it means to be human. It becomes an exciting thing for us. this is a strange thing when people read read the scriptures that you that you give yourself away and you in service and you receive joy in it. And it's something people don't HOST MP3 (01:08:15.416) thing is is is we are growing and experiencing and if we if we love the vocation that we HOST MP3 (01:08:26.016) it then it becomes part of what it means to be human. It becomes an exciting thing for us. This is a strange thing when people read read the scriptures that you that you give yourself away and you in service and you receive joy in it. And it's something people don't understand until they start doing it. And when you start serving other people you start realizing that like how did I never have that in my life? Don't understand until they start doing it. And when you start serving other people, you start realizing that like, how did I never have that in my life before? and it becomes one of these things where you're just like, I want to do more and more and more. And this is like, if you look at the disciples, you you you think they're crazy, but it's not that they're crazy. it's they're they're giving everything away, they're doing all this stuff because they're getting joy from serving other people. And it becomes one of these things where you're just like, I want to do more and more and more. And this is like if you look at the disciples, you you you think they're crazy. But it's not that they're crazy. it's they're they're giving everything away, they're doing all this stuff, because they're getting joy from serving other people. And and part of what that points to is like maybe maybe the toil isn't the point of things. Right? Maybe this system isn't now. Is that disruptive? Yeah. And and part of what that points to is like maybe maybe the toil isn't the point of things, right? Maybe this system isn't now. Is that disruptive? Yes, in a big way. And does that make people uncomfortable? Yes, in a big way, because if you've known your life a certain way, thinking about how it's going to be different is going to be a challenge. But I mean, we've watched right here in Miami, it's like, you know, every once in a while I go pull away pull a robot delivery little R2 unit that somebody's driving somewhere, but pull it out of a pothole or something and help it on its way. HOST MP3 (01:09:25.387) In a big way. And does that make people uncomfortable? Yes, in a big way, because if you've known your life a certain way, thinking about how it's gonna be different is gonna be a challenge. But I mean we've watched right here in Miami, it's like, you know, every once in a while I go pull away pull a a robot delivery Like R2 unit that somebody's driving somewhere, but pull it out of a pothole or something and help it on its way, right? We see the Waymo's all over town automating automating that system. I'm sure within our lifetime we're gonna see Tesla lots. And if they start doing my laundry for me, robots are coming. Yeah. Yeah, and and then then we're gonna have to say we're gonna have to have the battle star relax. Right. We see the Waymo's all over town automating automating that system. I'm sure within our lifetime we're gonna see Tesla bots. And if they start doing my laundry for me, you know, gr great. Yeah, and and then then we're gonna have to say gonna have to have the Battlestar Galactica conversation at some point because if one of those proverbial cylons starts to say, Well, I've been thinking a lot about God, well then at what point do you take it seriously? At at what point do you say, Well are you supposed to be doing my laundry? Like like these these become proverbial silon starts to say well HOST MP3 (01:10:20.472) take it seriously. At what point do you say, well are you supposed to be doing my laundry? Like like these these become what we think now are existential questions, but they're they have the potential to become very tangible questions quickly. And they change about our they change our thoughts about how we interact with everything. what we think now are existential questions, but they're they have the potential to become very tangible questions quickly and they change about our they change our thoughts about how we interact with everything. And I think that's interesting. I mean when we talk about robots, like it starts to make us think about, well, what's our ethic regarding animals? That's alternative intelligence. And and I would say And I think that's interesting. I mean, when we talk about robots, like it starts to make us think about, well, what's our ethic regarding animals? That's alternative intelligence. And and I would say you want to make people uncomfortable real quick, start talking about animal ethics. and because there there are a whole bunch of things that we do and I'm not sure You want to make people uncomfortable real quick, start talking about animal ethics. and because there there are a whole bunch of things that we do and I'm not sure we justify that it's a good thing. We've just done it because for a while it was necessity and now it's convenience. And the question is, is like, well, do we need to do that? Like, if someone can create a beyond burger that you can't tell the difference, or somebody can do justify that it's a good thing. We've just done it because for a while it was necessity and now it's convenient. And the question is, is like, well do we need to do that? Like if someone could create a beyond burger that you can't tell the difference, or somebody can do grow lab grown meat. GUEST MP3 (01:11:27.67) grow lab grown meat and something doesn't have to die to kill it. At some point does our ethic need to change. These become ethical questions. And again, I'm not saying I'm not being prescriptive. I'm just saying it becomes something we need to consider at that point. Like, okay, well, why are we doing what we're doing? And and it's fascinating that we've got this far without asking some of those questions, isn't it? I mean You know, that's a And something doesn't have to die to kill it. At some point does our ethic need to change. These become ethical questions. And again, I'm not saying I'm not being prescriptive. I'm just saying it becomes something we need to consider at that point. Like, okay, well, why are we doing what we're doing? And and it's fascinating that we've got this far without asking some of those. I know that's why this is you know, that's every time I'm having this conversation, how did we get here without pushing our intellect in a way that really have these debates more and more. When we look at the past and the way we do things, they don't make any sense. Time I'm having this conversation, how did we get here without pushing our intellect in a way that really have these debates more and more? When we look at the past and the way we do things, they don't make any sense. Right, right. They don't in some cases. And and so so this is part of and and this is why, regardless again of your religious tradition, They don't in some cases. And and so so this is part of and and this is why, regardless again of your religious tradition. GUEST MP3 (01:12:27.948) Because there are different expressions of religion that I think so in my tradition, for example, if you and I disagree, I I would say, Well what what is God saying through him that maybe I don't see, that God's not saying through me? And vice versa, and usually the truth is in the middle, right? And so so there's actually I look at other traditions and go, Well, what do they see that I don't see? You know what I mean? Like what are the good things that I s that Because there are different expressions of religion that I think so in my tradition, for example, if you and I disagree, I I would say, well what what is God saying through him that maybe I don't see, that God's not saying through me? And vice versa, usually the truth is in the middle, right? And so so there's actually I look at other traditions and go, Well what do they see that I don't see? You know what I mean? Like what are the good things that I s that they have to offer that I don't see? they have to offer that I don't see. And and that starts shifting your understanding of good, right? Like we s it gives us wisdom. This is why being in my multi-ethnic congregation, it is wonderful. Because I one, I'm wildly unequipped to just do my job every day and people have so much grace with me because I'm always on a learning curve because someone speaks a language I've never even heard of before. They have a cultural thing. But the the excitement of learning and And and that starts shifting your understanding of good. It gives us wisdom. This is why being in my multi ethnic congregation it is wonderful. Because I one, I'm wildly unequipped to just do my job every day and people have so much grace with me because I'm always on a learning curve because someone speaks a language I've never even heard of before, they have a cultural thing. But the the excitement of learning right in that in kind of environment is a fascinating thing. And and the thing is is you don't even have to have multi ethnic diversity. GUEST MP3 (01:13:23.684) That kind of environment is a fascinating thing. And the thing is, is you don't even have to have multi-ethnic diversity. I've been in churches that were all white churches in the in the middle of nowhere, Ohio, right? And people are like, well, where is that place? I we don't know. But if you actually talk to people, they're very diverse in what they think. Right? So that diversity is all around, waiting for us to explore and to think about these things at a at a bigger level about who we are and what are we called to. I've been in churches that were all white churches in the in the middle of nowhere, Ohio, right? and people are like, well, where is that place? I we don't know. But if you actually talk to people, they're very diverse in what they think. Yeah. Right? So that diversity is all around, waiting for us to explore and to think about these things at a at a bigger level about who we are and what are we called to or meant to do. Who are meant to do. And I think that gets exciting. It gets scary if you're going to rip someone's house down and not give them a place to live. But if if we decide together that maybe the house wasn't the best place to live to begin with, we determine what the new living situation is, and then we tear it down together because we've already built this new future. Well, that's a very different conversation, and usually one that people enter into joyously. And I think that gets exciting. It gets scary if you're gonna rip someone's house down and not give them a place to live. But if if we decide together that maybe the house wasn't the best place to live to begin with, we determine what the new living situation is, and then we tear it down together because we've already built this new future, well that's a very different conversation, and usually one that people enter into Yeah, so much to think and so much to go through and so much to debate. It's it's it it touches all different aspects of our life and right, of our society and at a global scale, right? It's it's really everyone is trying to determine where things may be heading and how we're gonna get there. Well and I think one great thing is for for people watching the podcast is to say, well GUEST MP3 (01:14:24.546) Yeah, so much to think and so much to go through and so much to debate, it's it's it it touches all different aspects of our life, right? Of our society and at a global scale. it's really everyone is trying to determine where things may be heading and how we're gonna get there. Well and I think one great thing is for for the people watching the podcast is to say, well, what are you called to do now? Like what is what is like the tangible thing that you you can do? And I think this is like an important thing for us to think about is like What are you called to do now? Like what is what is like the tangible thing that you you can do? And I think this is like an important thing for us to think about is like, you know, what are what steps are you making to try to better your situation and and to better if you have family, your family situation or You know, w what are y what steps are you making to try to better your situation and and to better if you have family, your family situation or the people around you situation. And I think when we start to think through that tangibly and then we say, Well, how are we using these tools now to help in that process? Right? Like like I told you, I do I need to run a marathon? No. I I don't no one in their right mind needs to run a marathon. But but think when we start to think through that tangibly and then we say well how are we using these tools now to help in that HOST MP3 (01:15:26.872) Do I need to run a marathon? No. I I don't no one in their right mind needs to run a marathon. But but the thing is, is I want to do something that challenges me. Right. I want to do something that pushes me to see, like, okay, what what am I capable of doing? And and so what are the things that are pushing people? How are how are you using the technology in a practical way? And to constantly be reevaluating that because The thing is, is I want to do something that challenges me. I want to do something that pushes me to see, like, okay, what what am I capable of doing? And and so what are the things that are pushing people? How are how are you using the technology in a practical way? And to constantly be re-evaluating that, because the difference between us pursuing that good. The difference between us pursuing that good is the difference between our communities being great, or us going into some of those black mirror situations. Our church does something really simple every month. Actually, this morning I've I'm missing it to be here with you. But they they have a cleanup in Brickle where they once a month they people meet and they they gather just to pick up garbage, right? And you would go, Well, that's not that big a deal. Is the difference between our communities being great or us going into some of those black mirror situations? Our church does something really simple every month. Actually, this morning I've I'm missing it to be here with you. but they they have a cleanup in Brickle where they once a month they people meet and they they gather just to pick up garbage, right? And you would go, Well, that's not that big a deal. Yeah, it it takes people an hour and they go around and they pick up a bunch of garbage. But you know what? There's always garbage there. And they'll keep picking up garbage until there's not garbage, right? Now what if everybody in all of Miami took one Saturday a month and everybody went outside and we picked up the garbage and all the thing? Like like and and then we probably have to have a conversation like, Well, what's happening with this garbage? Mm-hmm. HOST MP3 (01:16:23.564) Yeah, it it takes people an hour and they go around and they pick up a bunch of garbage. But you know what? There's always garbage there. And they'll keep picking up garbage until there's not garbage, right? Now what if everybody in all Miami took one Saturday a month and everybody went outside and we picked up Like and and then we probably have to have a conversation like well what's happening with this garbage? Mm-hmm. And where's this garbage going? Mm-hmm. And what's the you know, like I'm not sure that and how we can minimize this garbage maybe. Like maybe we don't actually need all that hour to pick all this up because maybe then everyone becomes And where's this garbage going? And what's the you know, like I'm not sure that the recycling's minimize this garbage? And how can we minimize the garbage? Like maybe we don't actually need an hour to pick all this up because maybe then everyone becomes conscious of the fact. But see, there have to be people who are willing to go out and do the thing over and over and over and be the visible witness to be the visible witness of doing that. And no one has to start and that's where podc But see people who are HOST MP3 (01:17:11.246) To get started. To be the visible witness of doing that. Someone has to start. And that's where podcasts like this are important because you're not saying, hey, I have all the answers. You're saying, hey, let's bring some people to help us think differently about it, and then let me think about my life and how I can go and and pick up the proverbial Like this are important because you're not saying, Hey, I have all the answers. You're saying, Hey, let's bring some people to help us think differently about it, and then let me think about my life and how I can go and and pick up the proverbial garbage in my area, start to reshape things, actually to create some things that are beautiful. and and I think that's the wonderful thing about being human is God has entrusted us to shape our communities and to shape the start to reshape things, actually to create some things that are beautiful. and and I think that's the wonderful thing about being human is God has entrusted us to shape our communities and to shape the world that we're in in such profound ways. so I I world that we're in in such profound ways. so I I'm I'm actually really excited. I'm a tech optimist, because of my eschatological view of things. but I I think it doesn't mean there won't be speed bumps. It doesn't mean we won't make mistakes. but I really believe I believe in humanity, I believe in people doing good things. And I think the more that we advocate this, the more conversations we have about it, the more we put it in pr presently in people's mind, the more and more I see people stepping up to the task. HOST MP3 (01:17:52.0) I'm actually really excited. I'm a tech optimist because of my eschatological view of things. but I I think it doesn't mean there won't be speed bumps. It doesn't mean we won't make mistakes. but I really believe I believe in humanity, I believe in people doing good things. And I think the more that we advocate this, the more conversations we have about it, the more we put it in pr presently in people's mind, the more and more I see people stepping up to the I'm wondering Chris if you and the church has a view on the whole conversation around UBI. Yeah. And how we're gonna take care of people if the if what's coming is more automation, more jobs being automated, right? Meaning less work for us to do. Is there do you have any position, any thoughts on on that? Yeah, I think I think the dangers Chris, if you and the church has a view on the whole conversation around UBI. Yeah. And how we're gonna take care of people if the if what's coming is more automation, more jobs being automated, right? Meaning less work for us to do. Is there do you have any position, any thoughts on on that? Yeah, I think I think the dangers I I I don't think anyone has a convincing position at this point, is my personal opinion. I I think the dangers of of this at this point is we've experienced history. I I I don't think anyone has a convincing position at this point, is my personal opinion. I I think the dangers of of this at this point is we've experienced history and we've seen communist regimes, for example, that have promised similar things. the reality is is in here in Miami we have people who live under communist regime regimes and moved here GUEST MP3 (01:18:57.74) And we've seen communist regimes, for example, that have promised similar things. the reality is is in here in Miami we have people who live under communist re regimes and moved here because of that. and so when you talk about communism or s yeah. Yeah, so so there's people who know the dangers of that and it's a real thing. And and here when politicians talk about like like if you say don't of that. Yep. and so when you talk about communism, I did I come from Cuba. So so there's people who know the dangers of that and it's a real thing. And and here when politicians talk about like Like if you say don't let socialism invade our comf country, here that means something because people lived under it. In other places of the United States it doesn't mean the same thing. It it's an existential question to them, not a practical one. So I'm skeptical, frankly, because of total depravity, like even with the best of intentions, people do bad things. Right. they hurt people unintentionally sometimes. I'm skeptical that of political leaders that we don't trust Don't let socialism invade our comf country. Here that means something because people lived under it. In other places of the United States, it doesn't mean the same thing. It it's an existential question to them, not a practical one. So I'm skeptical, frankly, because of total depravity, like even with the best of intentions, people do bad things. they hurt people unintentionally sometimes. I'm skeptical that of political leaders that we don't trust now to enact some kind of universal basic income and not distort it for their own advantage. HOST MP3 (01:19:56.386) now to enact some kind of universal basic income and not distort it for their own advantage. Mm-hmm. I think the the f question before we get to that question, it's not to say never, mm-hmm, but it's just because the church actually had a version of this. If you look in the Acts of the Apostles, so women in first century Judea had I think the the f question before we get to that question, it's not to say never. but it's just because the church actually had a version of this. If you look in the Acts of the Apostles, so women in first century Judea had not many rights at all. it was usually associated with their husband or their family. If their husband died, if the husband had a brother, in in Jewish circles they would marry and it would kind of go through this process. But if you didn't have somebody else and you were widowed, your options were pretty grim. I mean, could be prostitution, your kids. Not many rights at all. It was usually associated with their husband or their family. If their husband died, if the husband had a marry and it would kind of go through this process. But if you didn't have somebody else and you were widowed, your options were pretty grim. HOST MP3 (01:20:41.518) I mean, could be prostitution, your kids could get prostituted, you'd be sold into slavery. So part of the church's growth happened when in Acts when they said, You're welcome. Come and we'll figure it out with you. You are worthy as people, come be part of it. So this is how the deacons are established in the church, because it's for an administrative purpose. They the the apostles can't deal with all the w the women and children that are coming because all these widows and their husbands are coming. Kids could get prostituted, you could be sold into slavery. So part of the church's growth happened when in Acts when they said, You're welcome. Come and we'll figure it out with you. You are worthy as people, come be part of it. So this is how the deacons are established in the church because it's for an administrative purpose. They the the apostles can't deal with all the w the women and children that are coming because all these widows and their orphans are coming. And then they have a financial problem. And then they have a financial problem. Like we have to feed these people. And we don't have the money. So people literally are going and selling their houses, they're selling their stuff to help take care of of the need. So there is some sense of that in the church, but it was all willingness, right? It wasn't imposed from somebody. It was this willing now you could argue, did God impose that? Well, that's Like we have to feed these people, and we don't have the money. So people literally are going and selling their houses, they're selling their stuff to help take care of the need. So there is some sense of that in the church, but it was all willingness, right? It wasn't imposed from somebody. It was this willing. Now you could argue, did God impose it? Well, that's a whole nother theological conversation. So so the question then becomes: is like So so the question then becomes is like for me fundamentally is well, how do we get to a place where we actually trust politicians? I think we have to answer that question before, because if I'm in community with you and I know you and I know you well, well then I don't have any problem with you overseeing something that has to do with my welfare. It's it's the apostles overseeing GUEST MP3 (01:21:40.448) for me fundamentally is well how do we get to a place where we actually trust politicians? I think we have to answer that question before because if I'm in community with you and I know you and I know you well, well then I don't have any problem with you overseeing something that has to do with my welfare. It's it's The apostles overseeing overseeing the welfare of people, people trusted them. They they had trust. They trusted deacons. Those widows and orphans wouldn't have shown up if there wasn't some level of trust. They they would just take their chances, right? So Yeah. So right now we have a trust issue and part of the reason we have a trust issue is we have an integrity issue. and and I think the thing about technology is it's going to reveal more and more about who we really are to one another. It's gonna be more overseeing the welfare of people, people trusted them. Right. They they had trust. They trusted deacons. Right. Those widows and orphans wouldn't have shown up if there wasn't some level of trust. Right. They they would just take their chances, right? That's the key of all that. Yeah. So right now we have a trust issue and part of the reason we have a trust issue is we have an integrity issue. and and I think the thing about technology is it's going to reveal more and more GUEST MP3 (01:22:31.546) It's gonna be harder to hide most of the bad things to Yeah, and I think what it's gonna require is instead of demonizing one another on everything, it's gonna require us to change our behaviors, but it's also gonna require us to have a lot more grace with people and to realize that like some of the things that we've said are bad in the past aren't as bad as we think they are, and some of the things that we've said are good aren't as good as they we think they are. And and build the trust system and if we Expose the bad things, you know, all that. And I think what it's gonna require is instead of demonizing HOST MP3 (01:22:48.12) that like some of the things that we've said are bad in the past. Some of the things that we've said are good, aren't as good as they we think they are. And and build a trust system. And if we are able to build a trust system, then we might be able to think about are able to build a trust system, then we might be able to think about a new way of doing things. The other thing is is I I've not seen, you know, the old school understandings of capitalism was there was a a benevolent capitalism The other thing is, is I I'm not seeing, you know, the old school understandings of capitalism was there was a a benevolent capitalism. That might be an in-between right now for us to see, and it would be great to actually see how tech companies that have billions and billions of dollars, what what benevolent capitalism looks like. It's not to say the government is telling them how to be benevolent. That might be an in-between right now for us to see. And it would be great to actually see how tech companies that have billions and billions of dollars, what what benevolent capitalism looks like. It's not to say the government is telling them how to be benevolent, but it's to say how are billionaires, particularly as they come into Miami. HOST MP3 (01:23:33.784) But it's to say how are billionaires, particularly as they come into Miami, how are they partnering with people for the community welfare? You know, there was a time in in in the United States when there was the Gilded Age, right? And the Gilded Age was the understanding was all these big tech tech people of their age, right? They were there were railroad and steel and all sorts of, you know, various inventions that came about at the time, how they were being philanthropic to people. How are they partnering with people for the community welfare? You know, there was a time in in in the United States when there was the Gilded Age, right? And the Gilded Age was the understanding was all these big tech tech people of their age, right? They were railroad and steel and all sorts of you know various inventions that came about at the time, how they were being philanthropic to people. They they went from the Gilded Age to be calling them robber barons because They they went from the Gilded Age to be calling them robber barons because then people realized actually how they made that money, which was by creating monopolies, strong arming people, by not treating their workers very well. And this is where you unions came up and you had antitrust laws were created, right? And society generally had a shift back the other way. I think we're in very similar situation now, where we have a very powerful few people. Then people realized actually how they made that money, which was by creating monopolies, strong arming people, by not treating their workers very well. And this is where you unions came up and you had antitrust laws were created, right? And society generally had a shift back the other way. I think we're in a very similar situation now, where we have a very powerful few people in tech right now, and there's some people I Elon Musk is a great example of this. And there's some people I Elon Musk is great example as a you know, richest man s since Rockefeller, right? And and Rockefeller and and Musk have kind of the same approach. When Elon bought Twitter, right, everyone loved Elon before he bought Twitter. GUEST MP3 (01:24:38.096) you know, richest man since Rockefeller, right? And and Rockefeller and and Musk have kind of the same approach. When Elon bought Twitter, right? Everyone loved Elon before he bought Twitter, and now half the people love Elon because they know who Elon is and some people like it and some people don't. And Elon's approach is, yeah, that's the cost of doing business. Not everyone's gonna like you. The question is, is like, well, what They know who Elon is and some people like it and some people don't. And Elon's approach is, yeah, that's a cost of doing business. Not everyone's gonna like you. The question is, is like, well, what what are you trusting communities with for the betterment of community? And in fairness to billionaires, I don't think they should just hand their money over to people who don't have a plan because there are a lot of people throwing money at the wall because they don't know the answer forward. What are you trusting communities with for the betterment of community? And in fairness to billionaires, I don't think they should just hand their money over to people who don't have a plan because there are a lot of people throwing money at the wall because they don't know the answer forward. But I think it would be great if billionaires would help to say, hey, for example, we're moving to Miami. What is the systemic approach to addressing homelessness? But I think it would be great if billionaires would help to say, hey, for example, we're moving to Miami. What is the systemic approach to addressing homelessness? How can we help people on the ground systemically deal with it? Now, if you take an Elon Musk, critique him as much as you will on things. How can we help people on the ground systemically deal with it? Now, if you take an Elon Musk. GUEST MP3 (01:25:41.134) Critique him as much as you will on things, but you can't say Elon Musk doesn't understand systems. You don't build rockets and and things that have to go together completely. Like, so Elon Musk gotta be able to look at someone's approach to homelessness and put a team of people together and be able to say, okay, where are some of the system flaws and how can we start fixing that and create a comprehensive thing? Now, is that always gonna be the fix? Maybe not, because systems change, things change, but it's a place where we can start to address But you can't say Elon Musk doesn't understand systems. You don't build rockets and and things that have to go. Absolutely. Like so Elon Musk gotta be able to look at someone's approach to homelessness and put a team of people together and be able to say, Okay, where are some of the system flaws and how can we start fixing that and create a conference? Now, is that always going to be the fix? Maybe not, because systems change, things change. But it's a place where we can start to address some of these larger social issues. I think this is how you build trust to go to those deeper things. If you said, hey, we're gonna have a universal basic income tomorrow and Elon Musk's gonna be in charge of it, you'd have rides in the streets. if you said you're gonna have universal some of these larger social issues. I think this is how you build trust to go to those deeper things. If you said, hey, we're gonna have universal basic income tomorrow and Elon Musk's gonna be in charge with it, you'd have riots in the streets. if you said you're gonna have universal you know, some kind of universal basic income and our government's gonna administer it administer it, you'd have riots in the street. Why? Because there's a lack of trust. And so I think we can have those conversations at some point. I'm not suggesting whether it's a good suggestion or not at this point. I what I'm suggesting is we have work to do beforehand. A lot. A lot. A lot. HOST MP3 (01:26:26.52) Some kind of universal basic income and our government's gonna administer it administer it, you'd have riots in the street. Why? Because there's a lack of trust. And so I think we can have those conversations at some point. I'm not suggesting whether it's a good suggestion or not at this point. I what I'm suggesting is we have work to do beforehand. A lot. A lot. A lot. Chris, one last question. One last question to close out our exciting conversation today, something that I ask every guest on the show, which is what would be the piece of advice that you would give a ver a younger version of yourself watching that kit today, getting into this new future with AI? Do the work. do the work. Like don't be afraid of hard things. make sure that you're being intentional about how you're forming Close out our exciting conversation today, something that I ask every guest on the show, which is what would be the piece of advice that you would give a ver a younger version of yourself watching that kit today, getting into this new future with AI? HOST MP3 (01:27:17.484) Make sure that you're being intentional. being formed and and how you're forming yourself. this is When you think about if anybody's been in kind of classical education, there there are classes you need and there's classes you don't. And a discerning student will discern that pretty quickly, right? And and so it's like understand how you're being called, and then underst understand where it's important for you to do the work. and and and in places where it's easier to find the shortcut, there are some places where it is easier to find the shortcut. But but I think There there are classes you need and there's classes you don't. And a discerning student will discern that pretty quickly, right? And and so it's like understand how you're being called and then understand where it's important for you. in places where it's easier to find the shortcut. There are some places where it is easier to find the shortcut, but but I think formatively we can't avoid doing the work. we still have to go pick up the trash. GUEST MP3 (01:28:00.01) formatively we can't avoid doing the work. we still have to go pick up the trash or the proverbial trash and and we still have to do those things that make us better and and I think when people are committed to that, that is like compound interest over time. They see better and better versions of this themselves and they're and they're grateful for it over time. And and we still have to do those things that make us better. And and I think when people are committed to that, that is like compound interest over time. They see better and better versions of themselves and they're and they're grateful for it over time. Beautiful. Start with us will continue to be the case, right? Trying to find ways to help each other. Thank you one more time for being with us today. It's been a pleasure. Thank you. Okay. Beautiful. Start with us. We'll continue to be the case, right? Trying to find ways to help each other. Thank you one more time for Yes, thank you so much for having me. Yes. Thank you. HOST MP3 (01:28:39.276) Good? Alright. That was great. Thank you so much for having me. Yeah, absolutely. Right? Yeah. We make it we make it work. We make it work. Good. Good. Alright. Awesome. Great. Thank you so much for having me. Yeah. This is great too. So I mean this is like Right? Yeah, really great. We make it work. And you did it like quickly. Like I mean I'm impressed how quickly that that you did. I mean this I mean he has two cameras and I and I got one. He has one light and I got that one 'cause you know I I record a little remote. I mean he has two cameras, and I and I got one. he has one light and I got that one because you know I I record a low remote so I got my setup here and then I did the wall and the light. And it looks a little bit like a podcast studio and and it it it gets the job done. So I got my setup here. Yeah. And then I did the wall. Yeah, I mean this is great. And it looks a little bit like Custodial and and it it it gets the job done. Yeah, no, it's fantastic. How'd you do these? That's that's great. Yeah, you just it's on Amazon you get them and you just the slab holes you can glue them, yeah, or you can just drill them into the wall. Did what do you do? In my case we drill them, yeah. and then the lights you put it and you drill a hole. HOST MP3 (01:29:20.076) Yeah, exactly. That's great. Yeah, you just it's on Amazon you get them and you just the slat walls you can glue them or you can just drill them, right? What do you do? In my case we drill them. Yeah. and then the lights you put it and you drill a hole through it and you pass the the cables behind it. So it's the cable is behind it? The c the cables, all the cables are behind. Yeah. It looks great. So it's the cable is behind this? The the cables all the cables are behind. Wow. It looks great. I mean it really And now it's also beautiful because all the lights and Yeah, yeah, yeah. Yeah, no, it's so great. So she did a really great job. Yeah. And now it's also beautiful 'cause all the lights and stuff. Yeah. Yeah, no, it's so great. Yeah. I need your stuff today.