Cambridge Scholar On The End Of Mental Privacy | Ann Kristin Glenster
Hosted by Mykel Salomon · Featuring Ann Kristin Glenster · Published
Mykel Salomon is the founder of The Human Protocol Group, creator of The Human Protocol Framework, and host of The Human Protocol Podcast. He explores how technological change affects human beings, and what it takes to stay human while building the future.
Guest: Ann Kristin Glenster — I lead interdisciplinary research and policy programmes at the intersection of law, AI, and democratic governance, with a track record of translating rigorous scholarship into real world regulatory and institutional impact. I am a Research Professor at the University of Cambridge, founder of LOGOS at the Centre for Research in the Arts, Social Sciences and Humanities (CRASSH), and Executive Director of the Glenlead Centre. I design and direct large scale research initiatives, advise governments and regulators, and build trusted partnerships spanning academia, civil society, industry, and international institutions. Alongside policy leadership, I bring board level and executive experience in strategy, governance, fundraising, and team leadership across research centres, think tanks, and mission driven organisations. I am regularly engaged by national governments, regulators, universities, and philanthropic foundations, and my work has been featured in international media including the Financial Times, BBC, Reuters, The Sunday Times, The Times, Politico, and The Guardian. I am a sought-after public speaker on AI governance and in 2023, I led a senior level policy workshop on deceptive design for legislators and regulators at the Nobel Prize Summit in Washington DC. My expertise centres on AI governance, data protection, epistemic rights, intellectual property, deceptive design, digital education, and emerging technologies, including generative AI and neurotechnologies. I have authored more than 30 policy and research publications and have contributed directly to legislative, regulatory, and standards setting processes in the UK, EU, US, and UN system. My work has been cited in the Court of Justice of the European Union and by the UK House of Lords. I currently serve as a Member the Center for Humane Technology’s “AI and What Makes Us Human” Working Group and am an Affiliate of the Centre for Intellectual Property and Information Law (CIPIL) at the University of Cambridge. I am a former member of the Pool of Experts to the European Data Protection Board and a Technology and Human Rights Fellow at the Carr-Ryan Center for Human Rights at the Harvard Kennedy School for Government. I have previously taught at University of Cambridge, University of Oxford, Imperial College London, London School of Economics, Brown University, and Harvard University.
Ann Kristin Glenster is a Cambridge legal scholar who works on epistemic rights: your right to think freely, know what is true, and keep your mind your own. For most of history the law barely had to protect thought. Everyone assumed that what happened inside your head stayed there. That assumption is breaking in two directions at once. Feeds are built to shape what you think. Neurotechnology claims to read it, and as Ann is careful to say, we do not actually know that it does what it claims. Host Mykel Salomon and Ann Kristin Glenster work through what that costs us. A court that convicted a woman on a brain scan. Police forces requesting period-tracking data. The five things her Cambridge team says any system shaping your knowledge should pass. Why she thinks the whole conversation is backwards, chasing harm after it lands instead of saying what good looks like first. And what happens to a person when they can no longer tell what is true and quietly hand the thinking over, which she calls cognitive surrender. She is tech positive throughout, and unusually specific about what she wants instead. Chapters 00:00 A conviction built on a brain scan 02:10 Epistemic rights, defined in plain English 04:47 Freedom of thought when the system shapes thinking 06:38 Neurotechnology and what it only claims to read 08:02 The India case: a court reads a memory 09:34 Period-tracking data and the police 11:11 Promoting rights, not only defending them 13:03 The five: visibility, orientation, plurality, contestability, agency 13:37 Enforcement is what makes a right real 15:00 "Give me the checklist": what builders keep asking for 15:27 Streaming proved people choose the good option 16:22 Technical standards beat political point scoring 19:05 Article 358: where the law actually breaks 20:25 What it means to be human 21:15 Embodiment, vulnerability and why they matter 22:12 "We are perfect, all of us, just by being us" 24:21 Twenty chairs: a grandmother on consumerism 25:17 Students who cry when told they are fine as they are 26:46 What it actually means to be poor 30:06 Comparing yourself to a machine that never sleeps 31:22 If the job goes, who are you 33:13 What higher education is now for 35:20 The new frontiers of knowledge AI opens 36:36 Intellectual curiosity, and where it went 40:16 Stop designing systems where humans beat the machine 43:05 Cambridge taxi drivers and the value of another mind 45:20 Listening as a human skill 47:08 Why we are not allowed to be bored 49:26 Live slow: her mother's advice 50:32 Robots at home, and where it turns grey 52:55 The artist who asked ChatGPT to make his mother nicer 55:13 People disappearing from the information space 56:08 Militarisation and what it does to information 57:59 Epistemic chaos and cognitive surrender 58:39 Cognitive Extinction 61:12 The last question: advice to her younger self 62:46 The fight over AI is about your mind About the guest Ann Kristin Glenster is a legal scholar at the University of Cambridge and Senior Policy Adviser at the Minderoo Centre for Technology and Democracy. She holds a PhD in Law from Cambridge, with doctoral research at Harvard Law School, and has taught at Cambridge, Oxford, LSE, Harvard and Brown. She has published more than 25 policy papers, and her scholarship has been cited by an Advocate General at the Court of Justice of the European Union. Her current work is on epistemic rights and the regulation of neurotechnology. ---- ABOUT THE HOST Mykel Salomon is the founder of The Human Protocol Group, creator of The Human Protocol Framework, and host of The Human Protocol Podcast. He explores how technological change affects human beings, and what it takes to stay human while building the future. CONNECT WITH MYKEL Website: https://thehumanprotocolgroup.com LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/mykelsalomon Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/thehumanprotocolpodcast TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@thehumanprotocol BE A GUEST ON THE SHOW https://thehumanprotocolgroup.com/podcast/apply Subscribe and turn on notifications so you never miss an episode. The code may change. But our humanity is the constant
Conversation Summary
Ann Kristin Glenster joins The Human Protocol Podcast to discuss the erosion of mental privacy amidst advances in AI and neurotechnology. She highlights how technologies purportedly aiming to read our thoughts complicate the legal and moral landscape of epistemic rights—our rights to think freely and securely. Glenster, a legal scholar, critiques how the technological advances in reading and influencing thoughts challenge our foundational human abilities to discern truth and maintain private cognition. Throughout the episode, she advocates for defining what good looks like in technological development, rather than always reacting to harms after they occur.
“Yeah, I think this is this is a dilemma we're coming up against, and we haven't before, because we haven't had the technology.”
— Ann Kristin Glenster, guest
Neurotechnology promises versus reality
Glenster explains the contested promises of neurotechnology, which is claimed to read and interpret human thoughts. She warns that these technologies are not yet fully reliable and could lead to misinterpretations, exemplified by legal judgments based on questionable neuro-readings.
Epistemic rights in a digital age
Epistemic rights refer to the fundamental rights to think and know freely, something that technology today directly threatens. Glenster argues for stronger frameworks to ensure these rights are preserved as technology begins to shape human cognition.
The significance of setting standards
According to Glenster, specifying clear standards for what constitutes 'good' in AI and technology is crucial. Instead of addressing issues post-harm, the focus should be on proactive designs that protect human faculties.
“And and we're not gonna be able to forgive ourselves for not being super efficient and all of those things, right?”
— Ann Kristin Glenster, guest
Human identity beyond professional roles
As AI and technology reshape job roles, individuals may face identity crises when work is displaced. Glenster emphasizes the need to re-evaluate what constitutes human value beyond occupational identities.
Preserving intellectual curiosity
Glenster champions the preservation and nurturing of intellectual curiosity in educational contexts. With technology offering answers, fostering critical thinking and curiosity ensures people remain active participants in society.
The risk of cognitive surrender
As the informational space becomes increasingly chaotic, there is a risk of people surrendering their cognitive agency to machines. Glenster stresses the importance of empowering individuals to resist the temptation to let machines think for them.
“And I think this is one of those situations where may maybe we can we can see the complexity of this.”
— Ann Kristin Glenster, guest
Final Thoughts
Ann Kristin Glenster's conversation reveals the pressing issues around epistemic rights in the face of rapid technological advancements. As technology begins to influence and potentially control human thought, maintaining the essence of what it means to be human becomes increasingly crucial. Advocating for a proactive and collaborative approach that defines beneficial technology standards can help protect fundamental cognitive rights and ensure humanity's well-being.
Key Takeaways
- Neurotechnology promises versus reality
- Epistemic rights in a digital age
- The significance of setting standards
- Human identity beyond professional roles
- Preserving intellectual curiosity
- The risk of cognitive surrender
Frequently Asked Questions
What are epistemic rights?
Epistemic rights are the rights to think freely, know the truth, and maintain mental privacy, particularly threatened by technological advancements that aim to read and influence human thought.
How can neurotechnology affect legal outcomes?
Neurotechnology, which claims to read human thoughts, can affect legal outcomes by being used as evidence, even when its interpretations may be unreliable or inaccurate.
Why is setting standards for AI important?
Setting standards helps define what constitutes beneficial technology, aiming to prevent harm by establishing guidelines for developers to create technologies that respect human rights.
What does cognitive surrender mean?
Cognitive surrender refers to individuals conceding their decision-making and critical thinking processes to machines, resulting from overwhelming information and diminishing discernment between truth and falsehood.
How does Glenster view the relationship between human identity and work?
Glenster suggests that as AI influences job roles, there must be a re-evaluation of identity and value beyond professional roles to preserve human dignity and individuality.
Full Episode Transcript
This is the full recorded conversation from The Human Protocol Podcast, published by The Human Protocol Group. © 2026 The Human Protocol Group. Please link to and attribute the original episode when referencing this conversation.
THE HUMAN PROTOCOL (00:01.268) Welcome to the Human Protocol, the podcast about staying human while building the future. I am your host, Mykel Salomon. My guest walked into our first conversation straight from a room full of brilliant people all saying the phrase human centered AI, and none of them actually defining it. That's her whole project making the word human mean something again. Professor Ann Kristin Glenster Is a legal scholar at the University of Cambridge who works on epistemic rights, our rights to think freely, know truly, and keep our own inner lives, as machine increasingly think for us. She is tech positive, allergic to allergic to dogma, and she's gonna make this conversation very concrete and very soon. Welcome to the Human Protocol, Professor Anne Christine. Ann Kristin Glenster (01:00.13) Thank you so much. Absolute pleasure to be here. THE HUMAN PROTOCOL (01:03.836) Yes, it's a it's an actually an honor to have you on the show. Looking forward to this conversation. And and you're based in England, that's where Home is, right? Ann Kristin Glenster (01:13.782) Yes, I am. I'm actually in my home office in London, but my university is in Cambridge. So I get the best of a small town and a big city. THE HUMAN PROTOCOL (01:21.032) Okay. THE HUMAN PROTOCOL (01:25.66) Doesn't get better than that unless unless it's summertime and it's too hot, right? Ann Kristin Glenster (01:31.298) Yes, and it's it's we are we are struggling. We are struggling, but but we're optimistic for better times soon. THE HUMAN PROTOCOL (01:41.532) Yes, yes, th for sure they w they will come. and hopefully very soon. Professor N, I know that you're very passionate about this topic and which is freedom of thought, freedom of speech, mental privacy, human rights, all the things and different topics that in in in this era with AI we should try to continue to think about and and what does it mean for us human For us humans, right? And at the center of it all is this topic and conversation around and which is your current work, epistemic right. And I want to get started with this, because I think it's a fascinating topic that not a lot of people know that this is called epistemic right. In your own words, for most of us that we don't know what the term is used for, what does it mean and what do you mean with epistemic rights? Ann Kristin Glenster (02:42.115) you know, y as soon as you ask an academic to say something simple, it becomes complicated. That's the first question. So if we start with the word episteme, to know or to have knowledge, that is very specific for what we can do as human beings. And it's different from having just information. THE HUMAN PROTOCOL (02:47.257) I try, at least I try. THE HUMAN PROTOCOL (02:56.454) Ha ha Ann Kristin Glenster (03:11.659) I think what we do as human beings when we get information, data, we apply thinking and a broad set of thinking, also based on our emotional cap capabilities as well. So when we're talking about epistemic rights, this actually came out of some scholars in political philosophy who talked about it as something about how do we safeguard those very human features. And then it went into media studies because then we were talking about regulating the internet and so on. And then it sort of migrated into my field where we're really latching onto it, which is law. And what makes it unique? I mean there are several things here and w what which rights are we even talking about could be a question. But I think you started by saying I'm I'm tech positive and I really am. But that doesn't mean, you know, all sorts of tech for all sorts of reasons. It's it means something that serves us as human beings and the planet. And so Epistemic rights is a way to think of how do we build and engage with a digital and AI driven environment in ways that serve those faculties as human beings. So we're thinking about freedom of thought you mentioned, we're talking about freedom of expression, we're talking about mental privacy. So these are rights we already have in international human rights, but maybe we need to think about how do we interpret them. THE HUMAN PROTOCOL (04:26.842) Mm-hmm. Ann Kristin Glenster (04:39.583) in a modern context. And there's some other ones we can talk about, but that's sort of our starting point to think about of Islamic rights. THE HUMAN PROTOCOL (04:47.305) Yep, absolutely. And you bring it you bring it home right now because it feels like all this conversation with AI and and getting into into this whole new future, it's about not only r redesigning but rethinking what we think is freedom of thought, freedom of speech, especially in times with AI. For example, for me freedom of thought has been always been something that it's I care about, but then it makes me think now with AI and with the use of technology more and more. What is freedom of thought when really the system is designed to shape how we think? And it makes me think, are we talking enough about it? What is gonna be freedom of thought in the future if we are using these systems that are kind of designing and shaping our thoughts? Ann Kristin Glenster (05:43.223) Yeah, I think this is this is a dilemma we're coming up against, and we haven't before, because we haven't had the technology. So if you look at the jurisprudence, the history of how freedom of thought has been interpreted by the courts and so on, it's sort of not really gotten much attention because everybody thought, well, what happens inside your head stays inside your head, or nobody can access it. But now, as you mentioned, first of all, we have exactly the experience of if the environment around us, the intellectual environment, THE HUMAN PROTOCOL (06:02.975) Hm. Ann Kristin Glenster (06:13.162) information environment is totally sort of designed to make us think or feel a certain way. And we see that with psychometric profiling, we see it with surveillance capitalism and so on. How much free choice do we have? How much agency do we have? How how much are we actually able to to to pick the things we're we're interested in? And we we've seen that with polarization and echo chambers and so on. But then we have the next dimension that's coming in now, and that is neurotechnologies. Now this is hugely contested, and I am not a technologist or scientist. so I I can only you b you know explain it in terms of how my my scientific colleagues talk about it. But we know that neurotechnologies are first of all, we don't know that they do what they claim to do. So they infer thoughts, but we don't know that that's true or not. You know, they'll say, this part of your brain, we measured it, and it lit up when you said dog, and that's must be a memory. Well, we don't know that that's true, you know. So so suddenly we're having all these things about these technologies are meant to read our minds, maybe they do, maybe they don't, meant to shape our minds, maybe they do, maybe they don't. And then we find that based on how we interpret those things. THE HUMAN PROTOCOL (07:05.705) Mm mm. THE HUMAN PROTOCOL (07:12.133) Mm-hmm. THE HUMAN PROTOCOL (07:27.805) Hm. Ann Kristin Glenster (07:34.2) So if I think you're thinking about dog, I might say, well, therefore we're going to, you know, put him in a kennel or something. Then then that also means that we are suddenly making values about human beings based on how we choose to interpret data that may not actually be related to how that person thinks or how they think of themselves. THE HUMAN PROTOCOL (07:57.279) Wow, it's a lot to think about. 'Cause could Ann Kristin Glenster (08:00.75) There's a lot to think about. Let me tell you about sort of horrific story and forgive me for for being not as an erudite as I should be, but there is a case in an Indian court, there's a couple of years ago, where a woman was told a narrative about how her husband was killed. And while she was told the narrative, her brain Activity was measured with one of these devices. And because of the way her brain lit up in these scans in various places, the court assumed or inferred that she had had a memory of killing her husband. And she was found guilty. And so you think this is madness, right? So it wasn't even that she said anything or did anything, it was based completely on this made up biological testimony. So I think that this idea of of safeguarding our intellectual processes and what that means to us and our epistemic rights and how that mixes with our environment, both technologically, but also how our bodies are interpreted, is going to be one of of the most important things we can think about going forward. THE HUMAN PROTOCOL (09:16.529) Yeah, especially in in situations like this, like this case that you just mentioned, it can technology can be used against us, right? Against our will. Ann Kristin Glenster (09:25.998) Absolutely. And we may not know how that's THE HUMAN PROTOCOL (09:31.779) And we made that exactly. Ann Kristin Glenster (09:34.231) Right. And so there there are, you know, we had another case that has been quite startling in the UK. I worked at a centre where we published a report on menstrual tracking devices. Now this is a very complicated area and and lots to say about that, but this is basically when women use a sort of Fitbit device to track when they're having the menstrual cycle in their periods. And As our researcher was finding out how this was being used, and we know that that data, we don't know it's accurate, we don't know how it's used, and so on. We've there was a newspaper report about English police forces in the same year that have requested that data in order to prosecute women for miscarriages for illegal abortions. And so you're thinking this makes you know, you wouldn't have thought so, not in England. THE HUMAN PROTOCOL (10:22.849) Ann Kristin Glenster (10:29.024) And so suddenly that sort of slippery slope of we just don't know how these things are going to be used in the future. you know, that's it it's it's it's it's closer than we thought, perhaps, some of these THE HUMAN PROTOCOL (10:41.891) A and you know you were just saying that and my mind is thinking about this. It's just it's it's it's we are very close from from getting from one extreme to the other. Because when you think the right should be there to protect us depending on the use of it, it can be used actually against us. And at the end of the day we're still a human being just there using it. And and what can we do to promote these rights more, not only defending them? Ann Kristin Glenster (11:18.196) I think we can well so so so at Cambridge what I'm working with on and with my team is to think about how can we make sort of conceptual frameworks or ideas for thinking about technology. And so if you have a conceptual framework, you can say, Okay, rather than just we we've done this with other things, like it does this cause harm. Well, if we have an idea of the harm, we can measure it against that and say, okay, what can we do design-wise to change that? And that's one the things we are thinking of. How do we make conceptual frameworks for epistemic rights? So that means that you can look at something like your Fitbit or something like that and say, okay, does this actually promote and safeguard your epistemic rights? And if not, How can we mitigate or do other things or can we give people a choice about it? And in some cases we shouldn't have a choice because we should just be protected. So I think yeah, you know, so I think that one of the things to think about. Now as we're talking about this, one of the things that one of my wonderful researchers did, she he did a fantastic graph that I'm not gonna show you, but you know, anyone who wants to look up our work, you know, d please find it. THE HUMAN PROTOCOL (12:15.672) We should. Ann Kristin Glenster (12:34.466) But on a lighthouse, because I think also when we're talking about epistemic rights and the things we're talking about, people will say, well, what about freedom of speech, for example? You know, you don't you don't want these sort of paternalistic, you know, restrictive rights. You know, there's also the freedom of of not engaging and having everything designed for us. And so what my research came up with is a wonderful thing of saying, well, epistemic rights are not about you know, forcing how we do with content. THE HUMAN PROTOCOL (12:43.373) Mm-hmm. Ann Kristin Glenster (13:03.81) But what he says it's about visibility, see so we can see what's happening. It's about orientation, so we can understand the direction of how our knowledge develops or not. That we have plurality, so we get exposed to different kinds of knowledge and information, contestability, we have the right to find out if something is factual, true or not. And we have agency, which means that when we have information. particular that concerns us, we can actually make choices. THE HUMAN PROTOCOL (13:37.238) Hmm. Who's gonna enforce all that? Because when I look and when I think about rights, Professor N, I think about rights in a way that it it should mean something. It they do, they usually do, but only if there is someone enforcing them. Because how how good is any given right if there is not someone enforcing and making sure that it gett it's protected? Ann Kristin Glenster (14:05.45) So to me, your question there is a sort of very typical legal question. And this is of course one of the things we we struggle with all the time. and you're quite right. One of the hardest things that we've seen with digital and AI tech is because it is global, because it's fast advancing, regulating it is near impossible. Right. So how do we start there? But I think if we have a framework to start on what we want good to look like. Then we can have choices to build on that. Right? Yeah. Rather than run after and say, okay, there's harm now, let's mitigate the harm. What do we start by a template saying, okay, this is what what good looks like? Let's give also the tech industry and others a chance to strive towards good. So I do a lot of work on ed tech, you know, digital technologies in in schools. And I THE HUMAN PROTOCOL (14:35.199) That's a good start. Yeah, I agree. THE HUMAN PROTOCOL (14:42.12) Yeah. THE HUMAN PROTOCOL (14:56.382) Mm-hmm. Ann Kristin Glenster (15:00.852) hear again and again from smaller companies. They sit there and say, give me the checklist. Give me what you want, rather than trying to retrofit. So I think that we as a as a sort of you you mentioned it human centered community, we haven't been good enough at articulating what we want. We keep saying we don't want this, we don't want this. But actually what if we go and say actually this is kind of the kind of things that I would want and we know from THE HUMAN PROTOCOL (15:08.402) Hm. THE HUMAN PROTOCOL (15:19.592) Yes. Ann Kristin Glenster (15:27.566) from other things in in industry and business that if you have a product that's superior and you give people choice, then they will of course choose a good product if they can. So for example we saw this with streaming, you know, in the 2000 around there, we started to have internet streaming and everybody downloaded illegally films from Hollywood. Why? Because we didn't have streaming services. The moment you have a safe and and you know trusted alternative, people actually want those things. So I think that's one of the things. When it comes to the legal regulation, very complicated, as you know, in in terms of how hard you go with enforcement, because we have legal rules, we have guidelines, we have treaties, we have standards, we have various things we can do. I have an on a very practical side, I believe in technical standards. THE HUMAN PROTOCOL (16:22.473) Okay. Ann Kristin Glenster (16:22.496) I think those are really good because that gives designers and software developers something to work with. And it's not as politicized and other things. It does be all about, you know, point scoring between two political fractions, which actually isn't that interesting. It's something where you can do something very practical. so I I think that that's one of the things to think about. But I also think we we we are seeing regulation in this field. So think about THE HUMAN PROTOCOL (16:30.48) Mm. THE HUMAN PROTOCOL (16:34.064) Right. Right. Ann Kristin Glenster (16:48.738) How social media is banned for under 16 in several jurisdictions now and so on, there's a will of society to adopt these rules. That said, last thing I'll say before I let you ask another question. when it comes to, as I said, a lot of these my starting point, a lot of these rights we already have. So it's not about new legal rules or new rights as such, it's about finding way to THE HUMAN PROTOCOL (17:03.365) No, it's okay. Ann Kristin Glenster (17:18.062) interpret the law we already have in a way that's meaningful for to technology today. THE HUMAN PROTOCOL (17:24.407) In and you know, especially when we look at the law from a global standard point of view, it's hard to make countries agree between each other in many different things. Imagine in this era with AI where everyone wants to be the first one and the winner, no one wants to look at regulation or agree with anyone on on safeguards. It feels like Europe is doing its own thing, US is doing its own thing. China is doing its something. And I keep looking and we all keep looking at this. And and I don't think anyone is is actually trying to go come to the middle and agree on okay, let's focus on really what does it good look like at least for us as a starting point. Right? Ann Kristin Glenster (18:14.23) I agree, right? And also with that, there is that question of that that's one of the reasons why I like the epistemic rights of tying it to sort of the universal human rights we already have, because I sort of say, okay, we've had a global agreement on something. You know, we've said these are the basics, this is the inalienable sort of this is what it means to be human. And that takes it away from again a conversation about content. For example, it's not about this kind of content or that kind of content because that's culturally sensitive. It's you know, some of some things obviously nobody wants like child pornography, but or child intimate, you know, sexual abuse images. But but in terms of saying, okay, what is it that makes us human? Let's start there. And then we can build some consensus on that. Where I find often with the legal bit though, Perhaps surprisingly, it's not so much getting to have agreement on these basic ideas. It is enforcement, as you said, which has to do with resources and expertise. That will be different, right? and then sort of yeah, the technical expertise down the line. So I always say, you know, when you have a big, complicated piece of legislation, it's not the first three articles where it says this is right or this is wrong, that's really THE HUMAN PROTOCOL (19:16.068) Mm-hmm. Ann Kristin Glenster (19:34.477) difficult. It's the article 358 that says that this is how this is going to be enforced. That is where the problems come. So I think that we also need to be realistic of what does it take to enforce things and how much do we want to enforce. So let's let's make a make a distinction between what's what good looks like that there are many different ways to achieve and then what does good look like and if you don't there's a stick of the law. And I do tend to have more faith in the first option, you wouldn't think so. Yeah. But in terms of the practicalities, but I do think the stick is also very important, right? so how do we find the balance is is tricky. THE HUMAN PROTOCOL (20:14.755) Starting there. Mm-hmm. THE HUMAN PROTOCOL (20:22.999) Yeah. How we find a balance, yeah. Especially especially between human beings, right? And and it's a perfect segue to to our next segment which is what it means to be human for you, Professor Anne. Ann Kristin Glenster (20:41.898) d this is you know, We've I think you and I touched on it before. This idea of what does it mean to be a physical human being is really central to me. Not just the intellectual human being or the emotional human being, but what does it mean to have a physical body? And so much in the AI discussion we sort of see a sort of transhumanist ideal that we're gonna upload our brains to a computer and live forever. And to me that is not what humanity is about. There's a psychiatrist in at the University of Heidelberg, Thomas Fuchs, who's written a gorgeous book called In Defense of Human Beings. And he talks about this embodiment. And so for me, I think that one of the things we don't focus enough on as human beings, and in what does that mean in this, these kind of conversations, is our vulnerabilities. Because that's what makes us human and that's what makes us also reach out to other people. the fact that we are vulnerable, we are dependent on each other. THE HUMAN PROTOCOL (21:36.117) Mm-hmm. Ann Kristin Glenster (21:44.899) That we need compassion, that we need empathy, that we make mistakes. So I think that there's that is an aspect of it, reality. And then the other aspect that I I I I feel that we are not really paying enough attention to is time. You know, this idea I talk a lot about like we should have the right to be bored, or we should have the right to look slow. THE HUMAN PROTOCOL (22:10.432) Mm-hmm. Ann Kristin Glenster (22:12.8) And we have this idea of efficiency that comes in with the AI narrative, efficiency optimization and augmentation and enhancement and all that. And and I don't believe in any of that. I think that we are perfect, all of us, just by being us. We cannot be otherwise because we as long as we're human and we're alive, we are by n by by default perfect. So this idea of constantly becoming something we're not, I'm I'm quite skeptical too. Of course we can improve skills and we can do certain things we can cure diseases and we can improve our health, but that's very different from saying we are not ideal as we are, right? And I'm so grateful that you and I are different, for example. You don't want to be Yeah, terrible, you know, if we if we were trying to be the same person. THE HUMAN PROTOCOL (22:58.341) Absolutely. Absolutely. THE HUMAN PROTOCOL (23:03.743) I I feel the same. I think we are perfect as we are. And the other day I was having a conversation with a friend, and all this conversation of course around how things are changing and and and and where are we heading next? And I mentioned to him, it's listen, why do we want to change our future so much? It feels like for some people they're just want to get us into this future that we see in the movies. Like it's a completely different world, everything it's all hyper optimized, robots doing the whole you know everything for us. Do we really want to go there? Do we really want to go there to change things so much? the way we live today. It's good. We can be improved, yes, but that doesn't mean changing drastically, right? Completely the way we live, the way we work. And and it feels like we're not being asked or we're not having as a society that conversation is slow things down for a minute. Don't rush it into the type of future that we maybe haven't asked to be part of. So Ann Kristin Glenster (24:21.292) I think I think I I I couldn't agree with you more. My grandmother used to say you know, you can only sit in one chair at a time. You know, so why do you need twenty chairs in your house, right? It's a sort of there there's just so much Yeah, you're right, she was right. She's like wh why do you need it? And there is something about this idea of consumerism that comes in with neoliberalism and so on, you know, and also that we're supposed again to improve ourselves, you know, to be more attractive or whatever it is. THE HUMAN PROTOCOL (24:35.152) That's a that's a perfect analogy, yes. Ann Kristin Glenster (24:51.126) Instead of just saying, why can't we just be here and now? Right? And and enjoy that. and also that that idea of the visual perfection that I think is very toxic. because of course that there is no such thing. But also we are all, as we just said, you know, perfect and beautiful. So th th th th there is not nothing to to to aspire to there. but this idea of dissatisfaction. I mean, there's a reason why we have rise of mental health. There are many reasons, but one of them is of course that we're constantly told we're not enough. You know, when I've taught summer school for high school students in Cambridge, and they they want to get into Cambridge, Oxford, or Harvard somewhere, every year I have had students on a one-on-one consultation cry and it THE HUMAN PROTOCOL (25:26.844) Mm. Ann Kristin Glenster (25:43.683) They cry at the moment I say, but you are fine as you are. And that's that's when they lose it, right? Because that's the first time somebody adult who is is in some sort of important position vis-a-vis their lives have recognized that they are just fine. THE HUMAN PROTOCOL (25:48.741) Wow. THE HUMAN PROTOCOL (26:00.623) The pressure is real on human beings. And it's in times of social media, it's it's it's it's easier to get down that rabbit hole of looking for perfection that for the most part it's actually fake because it's not real, right? People with perfect bodies, perfect lives, perfect relationships. And we are looking from this side of the screen saying, We are losers. We don't have anything that they have. It would be very nice to live their lives, but it's actually for the most part everything you're looking at perfection it's fake in social media. But we believe it and we feel it. And we don't feel like we are enough. And and that's a real problem. Ann Kristin Glenster (26:46.572) I think so, right? And I think, yeah, this constant sort of mirroring, right? and another thing there that I think about a lot is what does it mean to be poor? Because I think the this idea of poverty is only economic, I think is is is too narrow. For me, there's something about intellectual and creative richness as well. And so there's this idea of everything is about the money or the the house or yeah, the looks. THE HUMAN PROTOCOL (26:51.225) Yes. THE HUMAN PROTOCOL (27:05.09) Mm. THE HUMAN PROTOCOL (27:13.911) Yeah. Ann Kristin Glenster (27:15.138) And I'm thinking I feel incredibly rich because I y have so many books or I've read so much or I like to listen to music or you know, those experiences are incredibly enriching, or I have very rich social connections. To me, that's being wealthy and affluent and rich, right? THE HUMAN PROTOCOL (27:30.773) It's I absolutely. It's just the hyper focus on the looks and not on the actual how you feel as you know as human beings. Where your spirit is at, you know, what are the things that you feel alive doing? being poor doesn't necessarily mean that you don't have money. Sometimes you have all the money in the world but you are living an unhappy life. And you're not satisfied with anything that you have. For me, I'm with you, you know, if you feel good, if you have accomplished things in life that makes you, you know, feel like you have done things right, of course you're already rich for the most part. Ann Kristin Glenster (28:20.428) I think so, right? And every and we have so many surveys and things that says that what's good for people's sense of happiness and contentment is to have rich social relations. You know, people who have good relations with their family or friends or partners or children, whatever it is, whoever it is, right? Or or animals, but that having being part of a community, a fabric of social relations, being validated by people you care and respect. Those things make us rich, right? So that to me that the sort of what is what is the point of life is not just, you know, to storm towards the grave with lots of you know, these sort of perfect accolades or or or or tons of money. It's it's something about life happens while we're here. And those values are really important and they only happen in our bodies, in our real connections, right? So I think that THE HUMAN PROTOCOL (29:09.92) Yeah. Ann Kristin Glenster (29:17.24) There's there's a lot in the AI narrative and digital narrative that is sort of taking away some or or steering us away from some of our basic human values and and and and and experiences that that n frankly it doesn't interest me and I don't think it interests you either. THE HUMAN PROTOCOL (29:26.217) Yeah. Exactly. THE HUMAN PROTOCOL (29:37.15) No, it's the hyper focus on optimization on and becoming something that we don't we're not. We are human beings, we're not robots. We're not gonna be efficient twenty four seven and that is okay. That should be okay. You should not and then it is a challenge, Professor Ann, because for people working now with AI, you know, you have your job, but now it's not only you as the human doing the task, now you probably have an AI. you know, colleague doing part of your job. And people are starting to compare to each other, like, okay, the AI can do most of the tasks that I used to do. 24 7 doesn't sleep. And it's a real challenge because now we are not comparing only us humans to other humans. But now we're comparing to an actual machine that is nonstop and it is designed to be nonstop. And it's not helping with this. 'Cause what is our sense of effort and our sense of we being efficient if we start comparing to what the machine can do next? Of course we're not gonna be able to catch up to that. Ann Kristin Glenster (30:53.26) And and we're not gonna be able to forgive ourselves for not being super efficient and all of those things, right? And that and I think that is one of the things that that that really worries me is this sort of relentless gaze of like you can't make mistakes or we can't let our minds roam or we can't drop things or we can't you know, sometimes say things are clumsy and so on. You know, that there is this hyper efficiency. and it's it's THE HUMAN PROTOCOL (30:57.179) Exactly. Ann Kristin Glenster (31:22.134) You know, for certain things we want it, you know, but but for a lot of things we don't. And I think what you say there is also really interesting when it comes to how much of our identity for many of us, not all, but for many of us, is in the in our professional identity. Now, of course I say not you know, there are people who don't work, there are people who for all sorts of reasons and you know, but but for those of us who do, you know w we do have a sense of who we are through that and now in the future if we don't know those w jobs are gonna exist, who are we going to be? THE HUMAN PROTOCOL (32:02.205) Who are we going to be exactly? And for the majority of our lives, we haven't had the chance to have this conversation with ourselves. Really. Who are we? Right? And for a lot of people that have lived their lives as their job on the roles, it's really who they are. It's it's gonna be a challenging time coming to that type of conversation with themselves and trying to discover who they are that is not their jobs. And and I would like people to think about that 'cause it is important now more than ever most probably to really know ourselves. Ann Kristin Glenster (32:35.822) Excellent. Ann Kristin Glenster (32:44.468) Exactly. And also then what happens if if that sense of value came from that identity, right? And so you go in and say, Okay, well if that has no value anymore, or I I could only do it this good. I thought I was really good, but you know, now the AI comes or whatever it is. and I think this is something for us to really think about when it comes to our younger generations, because they're the ones who are struggling. I mean we're all struggling, you know THE HUMAN PROTOCOL (32:49.862) Discent. Ann Kristin Glenster (33:13.432) Don't get me wrong, we're all struggling with AI. But in terms of what do they choose to do. So I work a lot, as you know, in higher education, obviously I'm a professor at university, but in terms of what how does AI impact higher education? And what I hear from my colleagues, particularly in the US, is they say we can no longer stand by the narrative of if you go to college and you get a bachelor's degree, you will have a job. And so because we don't know that those skills are the skills you're going to use tomorrow, right? And we don't know what the work is going to look like. So we are not sure why we're educating you or how we're educating you or what's going to happen with those skills later on. So all young people are seeing is debt. THE HUMAN PROTOCOL (34:02.21) It's a real challenge, Professor Anne. For everything, for the whole society. It's not only for the you know, the college graduates trying to figure out what the future is, but professors, the university as a body, you know, society as a whole. What's gonna happen with all of that? Ann Kristin Glenster (34:04.718) Yeah. Ann Kristin Glenster (34:24.078) Well, and it comes back to a couple of things we touched on. So one of the the the sort of facile things I hear is like, why do we need to have education if we can find all the facts online? You know, Chat GPT can tell me. Okay. Uhhuh. And I'm thinking, yes, but the point about education to me is not so much about finding a specific fact, but is about learning how to think. THE HUMAN PROTOCOL (34:49.026) Critical thinking, exactly. Ann Kristin Glenster (34:51.17) Yes. A method and how to evaluate sources and how to build foundational knowledge upon foundational knowledge in a systematic and structured way. That's I went into law because I wanted to learn to think in a legal way. And I learned that. That was my motivation, right? So I'm thinking this idea of how we develop our episteme, which is different from just reading or writing or encountering information, because that comes to insight and wisdom and all of those things. THE HUMAN PROTOCOL (34:59.35) Mm-hmm. THE HUMAN PROTOCOL (35:08.142) Mm. Ann Kristin Glenster (35:20.588) where we bring something of our own process but also a structured way. So I think there there are values for those things for us to think about. I think you and I've talked about before this idea of what the opportunities to I think now we've done a lot of doom and gloom, but you know, to take us in a tech optimist nature as you or direction, as you know, I'm really excited about the new frontiers of knowledge that this technology is going to give us. THE HUMAN PROTOCOL (35:48.11) Mm-hmm. Me too. Ann Kristin Glenster (35:49.679) Right. But it's gonna open up these vistas. You know, I I know I used the example with you before, like before we had statistics, there was a lot of things we didn't understand. Suddenly we understood a way of thinking, of of getting knowledge, because we had a method for it, we have a technology for it, and that opened up all sorts of wonderful things. So I think that AI will bring us these new frontiers or these new domains of knowledge. But what's important to me there? is that those are there for us as human beings, not just the machine. So so you know, one of my being sort of the the old grumpy professor I am, one of the real I I I I THE HUMAN PROTOCOL (36:20.406) Mm-hmm. THE HUMAN PROTOCOL (36:28.812) Is that what your students say of Professor N? Ann Kristin Glenster (36:34.862) I wouldn't dare ask them, right? But the old rocket professor I am, I keep banging on about saying what has happened to intellectual curiosity. That to me is a human trait that we really should foster and allow for because that can make use of these wonderful new technologies in in fantastic and unpredictable ways. And let's remember AI and large language models and so on are probabilistic, built on big data. So although they are quite you know, amazing in how they can reveal things and do things, they don't have the same capacity we do to do things that are just absolutely marvelous and and and unforeseeable. THE HUMAN PROTOCOL (37:17.461) Ma maybe that's where the conversation should be should be directed towards looking at higher education not only as a way to achieve a specific outcome, you go to higher education and you're gonna get a good job and good money, but maybe getting back to you know, the very basics of it's what is it to be educated? Critical thinking, intellectual development. You know, trying to get back higher education to really its core, which is educating and making us better humans. And of course, with AI, we probably are gonna continue to find ways to work on. But you know, maybe we should try to to get the higher education message in a way that it gets down to the human level as it should be. 'Cause I think lately higher education, especially here in the US, it's it's seen as a business, is seen as a way to make more money depending on the careers. And not a lot of conversation is it what is it gonna do for you, the human being, if you come through this program? And you know, critical thinking, that's what we all should be trying to to develop more, being better humans, more educated. There's so many benefits. out of that. And messaging is one that I think you know universities and colleges should be investing more time on redefining how we message higher education for this future that we're heading towards. And we still need smart people, we still need people that can think for themselves. And that should be something that you know having a higher education can benefit also. A lot. A lot on that because it's not easy. People don't know if they're gonna get a job in the future or what are they gonna be educated on. If we need to redesign how we teach, because now we have AIs and AI is being used to help with exams, etc. So we are in this messy middle right now, Professor N that there is a lot that we don't know. Probably in the next couple of years we're gonna THE HUMAN PROTOCOL (39:39.14) all parts of society we're gonna have a better understanding of where we're heading towards with AI. Ann Kristin Glenster (39:48.259) Yeah, I think so. And I think this idea of you know, so we see the impact with essay writing and all of those things. So there's a lot of debates about academic misconduct or not, and so on and so forth. And should students be allowed to use it, and if they're not, are they going to use it in real life? So what's why do why would we restrict it and so on? And I think whatever we do, let us not try to design systems where we're trying to make humans beat the machine. Right. This is like, let's just r you know, accept that certain things are the machines are great at and let them be and let us benefit from that. But as you say, let's then think about what is the purpose of education. What is it to be an educated person? And some of the conversations I find myself sitting in, we're going back to the basics and saying it's not just about getting that specific job, but it's about as you're talking about the cultural capital. THE HUMAN PROTOCOL (40:25.992) Mm-hmm. Ann Kristin Glenster (40:45.624) critical thinking, these skills, you know, and they can be also be emotional, like compassion and empathy, and so on. but that this idea of what is it to be a cultured person? That used to be the building's idea in Germany in the sort of 1800s and so on and 1700s. You know, that that's where people went to univers and they went on these big trips across Europe to look at art and look at, you know, various music and things. THE HUMAN PROTOCOL (40:49.616) Right. Yeah. Ann Kristin Glenster (41:11.81) And that's what meant to be a cultured person, be educated. And they read philosophy in various topics, subjects. But then another thing that's coming up now is this idea of teaching civic skills or citizenship. And what does it mean to live in a democracy? What does it mean to have responsibility towards our neighbours and so on. THE HUMAN PROTOCOL (41:34.566) Mm. Ann Kristin Glenster (41:39.841) And what does it mean to have a civilized conversation and respect other people's point of view and so on. And so we're finding that that that education has a role to play in how we collectively come together as a society and say this is this is the society we are shaping together. It can't just be me, myself, and I and my grades. You know, it has to be a collective social endeavor. THE HUMAN PROTOCOL (42:01.485) No, I can't. THE HUMAN PROTOCOL (42:08.119) And even with all the challenges of you know building and working and living within a society, it's still worth it you know, fighting for. Because there is so much more benefits than cons when we try to make a society thrive, right? Where we try to see each other and help each other to thrive together. There is a lot that we all learn from each other. And that's the beauty of of it all. We we briefly touch on it. We don't want to be the same, you and I, or the rest of us being the same. There's so much to learn from each other and to grow from those differences that at the end of the day, even with all the challenges that come from living in a collective society, it's still worthy of it. It's still totally worthy. Ann Kristin Glenster (43:05.068) I find that I I couldn't agree more on that too. I'm not particularly interested in the technology. I l I is you know, I I like good technology, I want to use it, I want it to be safe and and and and and and and do good things for us. but I'm really finding that I'm interested in human beings. And so I find think what what do I really like in my days? And I'm I'm quite open. I've I think how people think and they're they're you know. THE HUMAN PROTOCOL (43:22.457) Mm-hmm. Ann Kristin Glenster (43:32.269) their relationships and and and how they see the world is really fascinating. And I love it when I go up to Cambridge, particularly if I go we have quite spread out campus. And if I have to go somewhere in a taxi, because the taxi drivers in Cambridge are more the most chatty bunch you would ever encounter. And I love it because you really get to see that's a different perspective than my own. You know, we can have a real conversation. THE HUMAN PROTOCOL (43:52.099) Ha ha. Yeah. Absolutely. Ann Kristin Glenster (44:00.365) And it's not dogmatic and it's not we're trying to convince each other of one thing or the other, but they can tell me about their lives or their views and I'll sometimes go, my gosh, I never thought of that. Or that you know, that's a very different way of looking at something. And I find that quite vigorating. And I think that's part of what it is to be human. THE HUMAN PROTOCOL (44:22.429) Absolutely, it's learning from each other. Trying to understand why people think different from us. It's the beauty of it all. We don't need to agree in everything. We're never gonna agree in everything. But going through that process on how did you get to that point and and how you what logic you use to get there, sometimes we disagree on the outcome. But when you look at our the way we logically went from point A from point B, there is a lot that we learned there that sometimes we don't think about because bring brings perspective to us that maybe because of our culture, the way we were raised, the way we have been educated, we never thought because we never were exposed to those factors. And and I found that also fascinating as well. Ann Kristin Glenster (45:20.386) I think one of the things we are we are we are not good enough at as a society is to listen to actually pay attention and listen to other people you know with that open mind of actually wanting to to to see who they are and where they are in in their lives. and and I try to do that and not go in and you know the the sort of being also ready to be confronted with with views or ideas that I don't personally you know reaccept or whatever but still to say okay that let me hear where this is coming from and sometimes I find that things are absolutely bonkers and I go, my gosh, you know, how did this person end up at that point? but I do think that having you know, starting off actually having a dialogue with people and listening THE HUMAN PROTOCOL (45:56.127) Agree on orh. Ann Kristin Glenster (46:17.44) And not expect again everything to be so efficient. You know, that's sort of what how you know, even you and I now, one of the wonderful things about this conversation, unlike a lot of news media, is that we're not interrupting one another, we're not, you know, in the fast, we're not trying to trip each other up. It's not that fantastic thing. We're actually trying to explore something a little bit more in depth. Yeah, and you can all right. Yeah, absolutely. Yeah. THE HUMAN PROTOCOL (46:35.935) Mm-hmm. THE HUMAN PROTOCOL (46:40.531) Human. Absolutely. And that's the point of of of this and and you know looking to optimize everything and sometimes you know and and I know that this is a topic that you you you actually talk about, which is boredom, right? We allowing ourselves to be bored in the society that we live in today, even before AI arrived as as we know AI it is today, we were all living fast paced lives. Jobs doing a lot of things at at at the time. I do a lot of things at the same time, and sometimes I forget to hey, maybe it's good not to do anything and just be bored. What does it look like? What does it sound like to be bored? And why we avoid getting there or even having a conversation about being bored, we don't allow ourselves. It's like it's a bad word. In the US, for example for example, you're not allowed to be bored, you are allowed you you need to always be in you know producing, right? Because some people compare or feel or think that they are machines when we're not. Ann Kristin Glenster (48:06.838) Exactly. And it's seen as something negative. Right? It's a sort of yeah, it's like being sad. We don't want people to be sad. Well, that's also a natural emotion. You know, I think it's very good we can be sad and we can also be happy. THE HUMAN PROTOCOL (48:18.417) Mm. And cry, for example, you know? Ann Kristin Glenster (48:21.12) Absolutely. And let things matter. Because I think that's the thing too, you know, if I'm r upset with something or or sad, that means that I let something actually ha have a meaning to me. but I think with the boredom, you know, that there is a as I sometimes think about it this this craze for meditation. And I'm wondering, is that actually because people just need to be a bit bored? And they're like, look at it THE HUMAN PROTOCOL (48:43.776) Ha ha Ann Kristin Glenster (48:46.606) Not to say that all the people are meant to do that, you know, but but that's a sort of I didn't say I just want to sit and w look at the THE HUMAN PROTOCOL (48:54.102) I I yeah, I I'm guilty myself sometime I see people doing something and say, people have a lot of time on their plate. Ann Kristin Glenster (49:01.12) Yeah. You know, yeah, and you think, you know, there's sort of it th the s and you look at children, right? And children do all sorts of stupid, wonderful, repetitive things and you think, Well that's that's it's sort of facult and now we're overstimulating our children, right? And now it's rigorous play and it's like, you know, you're supposed to do this activity and the other instead of just letting them be and just y you know, finding out what they like and not. I I think that I try to I just try to take my mother's advice to live slow. You know, the sort of take a breath and don't hasten everywhere. You know, I r th the newspapers and magazines are full of things like how to be hyper efficient with your ten minutes while you're waiting for the you know, and I'm thinking, my gosh, I'm exhausted You know, I don't want to be hyper efficient. I just wanna maybe be me in my THE HUMAN PROTOCOL (49:52.45) Only reading that word we feel exhausted already. Follow these five steps to be hyper efficient or to accomplish this in ten seconds. Really? Ann Kristin Glenster (50:02.614) Yeah, exactly. And I'm thinking I don't want to be hypervision. I just I just, you know, want to make a cup of coffee. That's it. Yeah. Yeah. You know, so I think we're also letting this sort of the acceleration of the environment and this sort of the hype of that carry us away where we're we're expected to have this tempo of modern life that I I don't think it's it's conducive to being, as you say, human. THE HUMAN PROTOCOL (50:12.602) Yeah. THE HUMAN PROTOCOL (50:32.813) D do you see yourself having a robot in the future to help you with things and inside your home? curious to see how do you see that? Because you know, this future will have a lot of robots, probably mass production in the next few years, able to help with things at home. For example, some people say, yes, I want these robots to help me with dishwashing. Okay. Ann Kristin Glenster (51:02.84) So I I could totally see that. And I can see that in terms of if there's a physical impairment, for example, you know, you know, where you can't reach the shelf or you know, or or y we do have, you know, little vacuum robots. I don't have one, but you know, th there are lots of robots that we have it already. So I think and to me that's that's absolutely fine. Just like we have a dishwasher, why not have a robot that, you know, puts it in the cupboard? THE HUMAN PROTOCOL (51:12.296) Mm-hmm. THE HUMAN PROTOCOL (51:21.14) Mm. THE HUMAN PROTOCOL (51:30.934) Mm-hmm. Ann Kristin Glenster (51:31.715) Result that they had done, where I think we're in a sort of grey territory and I don't know what I feel about. And I know you and I've talked about it before, is when we have robots that are there to replicate or take on human traits and human relationships. And so I'm thinking, for example, about old people who get these sort of seals, you know, dementia patients and those sort of things. You're thinking, is that a good thing or not? And And or or sex robots, you know, where people start to have sort of emotional projections onto these plastic dolls. And yeah, exact exactly right. And then you're thinking, well, my my in my initial instinct is to say, gosh, no, absolutely not. But then I'm thinking, Really? Am I sure that that's that's the the take I want to take? But I do think this idea of THE HUMAN PROTOCOL (52:08.656) that's coming. I'm sure that's gonna come. Yeah. Ann Kristin Glenster (52:27.296) If we start to r to replace human relationships with these very pliable we know this replica girlfriend, for example, everybody got upset when that was shut down and so on. When that starts to impair our ability to de to engage with actual human beings, because actual human beings are forgetful and inattentive and quarrelsome and say not you know, mean things or and you know all of those things, if that doesn't, you know, if we don't know how to deal with that, that's difficult. I know I told you the story and and you mentioned it to me in sort of thinking about our conversation about that artist with the mother. And I think this is one of those situations where may maybe we can we can see the complexity of this. So I I met an artist who had a terrible relationship with his mother and told me that he would then put all of her written communication with him through. THE HUMAN PROTOCOL (53:06.549) Mm-hmm. Ann Kristin Glenster (53:24.846) A Chat GPT, yeah, something like that. Yeah, I think it was Chat GPT, and and asked Chat GPT to make her nicer. And she was, and he told me that this improved his relationship with his mother phenomenally, and he was willing to have a really strong relationship with her. But of course, it was mediated through this other technological interface had actually nothing to do with his the real. THE HUMAN PROTOCOL (53:26.614) I think, right? Yeah. Ann Kristin Glenster (53:52.035) Person that his mother was, but he created a persona to interact with. And he felt very satisfied with that. Now, of course, the difficulty there too is that this mother now has no say in how her, you know, the identity creates. But then a lot of us live rent-free in other people's, you know, heads for the creating ideas about this, right? So so these are some of the places where I think it's going to be incredible. THE HUMAN PROTOCOL (54:11.373) Exactly. Ann Kristin Glenster (54:19.086) incredibly difficult and why I'm so excited about the kind of work I get to do, which is like we get to think about this and realise there's so many questions, there's so much research, there's so many conversations we can have about this because there are lots of things we don't know. THE HUMAN PROTOCOL (54:34.107) A lot, a lot to build whatever that next society we're heading towards, it's it will require a lot of a lot of work, a lot of questions, a lot of debate, you know, a lot of conversations to to brainstorm, you know, try to understand what those good look like as as we were discussing earlier today. But a lot of challenges as well. And I know this is something also you we briefly touch on, Professor N about the whole geopolitical situation and where we are on. Wha w what worries you? Ann Kristin Glenster (55:13.326) So there are several things that worry me, but I think there are two things. And one one that you think about. But before that, back to the idea of the conversations we need to have and and how we collectively think about it. I am very worried that we're getting an information environment where people disappear. Because we're seeing these are huge data sets probabilistic Inferences being made, so suddenly we see certain indigenous communities fall out of the common space, right? Or certain people of color or things like that. And we're thinking we worked so hard to make sure we are much more inclusive and representative, and now suddenly we're sort of seeing people sort of fall out again, and I'm really worried about that. And that kind of leads to the next issue, which is In the moment where where geopolitically we're changing so much, I'm seeing move very quickly towards preparing for war. Whether there'll be a war or not, that is not for me to say. But we're seeing the rhetoric coming, we're seeing the spending coming, we're seeing the polarization coming that is cast in that militarization language, right? THE HUMAN PROTOCOL (56:32.325) Like a militarization, yeah. Ann Kristin Glenster (56:36.738) And I think even the the US current administration they've renamed what was it, the Department of Defense to the Department of War. That is a very good illustration of this. And then what happens to that information space if suddenly everything becomes about protecting the realm? Also for national security. And I think that we it's gonna be hard for us to protect what it is to be human, particularly those plural voices. the people who are perhaps not absolutely what whoever's in charge wants wants the the discourse to be because it'll be seen as as threatening, you know, the enemy within. And that worries me enormously. And who controls then what we see if we're talking about it as as you know, as the information space being weaponized. That, you know, how do we retain our humanity and that I think is also one of the huge challenges. THE HUMAN PROTOCOL (57:33.175) And the truth and the true because it's getting harder and harder to know what is reality versus fake news nowadays. And and the weaponization of social media and the y the use of AI to, you know, build those narratives, whatever they want to build it and people not knowing what is true anymore. That's a really concern to me. Ann Kristin Glenster (57:59.405) And that causes epistemic chaos. Epistemic chaos. And with that, what we're seeing is that then people start to not just distrust things that might be false, but they distrust what is true. And then the result we're seeing so far is what you know, that sort of cognitive surrender or cognitive offloading. But people say, I can't think about this myself, it's too complicated, it's too difficult to discern. THE HUMAN PROTOCOL (58:02.015) Exactly. Ann Kristin Glenster (58:27.778) Therefore I'm gonna ask the AI to do the thinking for me. THE HUMAN PROTOCOL (58:31.513) So we're gonna le be leaving our critical thinking on everything for the system to make those decisions for us. Ann Kristin Glenster (58:39.692) And so unless we build good, we might end up where Nita Farragani at Duke University, I think she's at Duke, is writing a book called Cognitive Extinction. And I hope, you know, she's not, you know, I haven't read it, it's coming out. but but I hope we're not going into that world. I hope we can claim this space back or even fortify it, 'cause we still have a human epistemic world. THE HUMAN PROTOCOL (59:05.386) Wow. You you make me think now 'cause I haven't gotten to that point to think about all this conversation on that type of surrender, right? Our cognitive surrender because we are not able anymore to determine what's true versus what not true and we're basically just giving up, right? If this is too complicated for me, I'm just giving up. Let's use AI to make that decision for me because it's easier. Why am gonna worry when I cannot determine what is true? Ann Kristin Glenster (59:39.169) Exactly. Exactly. And we do see that. And people are are overwhelmed by the information. You know, there's that too. And because we're constantly stimulated, we don't have that time and space to reflect and breathe and think, you know, is this true? To be bored? That is my mantra. Yes, this is my movement. THE HUMAN PROTOCOL (59:53.376) Yes. THE HUMAN PROTOCOL (59:57.74) To to be bored. Get bored people. THE HUMAN PROTOCOL (01:00:04.96) Ha ha ha Ann Kristin Glenster (01:00:06.43) The boredom movement, come join me. Let's sit and stare at the wall. That's gonna be our action. You know, but I I think that this is, you know, it's it's a wonderful, exciting time for us all, but it's also really pivotal. And we know the cliches where I say, this is like it's never been so daunting as as well changes, but there are some foundational things that are changing. And and and THE HUMAN PROTOCOL (01:00:10.693) it's time to be bored. Okay, I go there. Ann Kristin Glenster (01:00:34.794) I think together we can think very you know very well about it and to protect and and and promote ourselves as humans. but only if we choose to. THE HUMAN PROTOCOL (01:00:45.958) Only we choose to, only if we allow ourselves to get there. And to put in the work. It's gonna require a lot of work, a lot of dialogue, a lot of you know, understanding what do we want, a lot of, you know, getting to the middle of it instead of staying on the extremes of it. and and you know, Professor N, we are almost at the end of it. Ann Kristin Glenster (01:00:49.89) Exactly. THE HUMAN PROTOCOL (01:01:12.062) and I want to finish with one question that I ask every single guest, which is what would be the piece of advice you would give a younger version of yourself watching that young lady getting to this new feature with the eye? Ann Kristin Glenster (01:01:28.724) I think I would say what I would always say to myself, read more books. Simple as that. In paper. In paper. You know, I read ferociously and I underline and I go back and I look at my intellectual journey. And I can see like I would have underlined something else today, right? And I love that discovery over time. And so I would say letting myself be more intellectual curious. And I was I was quite a lot. and then THE HUMAN PROTOCOL (01:01:34.056) Read more books. Ann Kristin Glenster (01:01:59.02) Finally though, I will sneak in. I think also this idea of how do we make sure that everybody gets to be part of these conversations. And so yeah, and so for that young person, I think that whoever you are, you have a right to a voice in this. And that to me is is really important. You know, it's not just those of us in particular institutions or ages or whatever. THE HUMAN PROTOCOL (01:02:10.365) That should be our goal. Ann Kristin Glenster (01:02:28.638) or or or power positions. This actually concerns all of us. We all should have a say. THE HUMAN PROTOCOL (01:02:36.284) Beautiful. Thank you for that. It's been an absolute pleasure to have you with us in the show. Can appreciate you more. Ann Kristin Glenster (01:02:43.576) Thank you. It's been a pleasure. THE HUMAN PROTOCOL (01:02:46.608) And if you take one thing from today, the fight over AI isn't only about jobs or safety, it is about your mind, our mind. Your right to think your own thoughts, to know things for yourself, and to be bored, to dream and to make your own memories. Thank you for being with us today and talk to you all next week. Bye.