The Soul Question: Faith, AI and Being Human

Faith, formation, and what it means to stay human when everything can be upgraded

By Mykel Salomon Β·

πŸ”“ Opening Reflection

About a decade ago, a pastor in Ohio started talking publicly about artificial intelligence.

A British tabloid ran his photo on the front of its tech section next to Elon Musk, Bill Gates, and Stephen Hawking. They never interviewed him. And suddenly reporters from all over the world wanted to know what a minister had to say about machines. Was he going to baptize their Roombas? What happens when you pour holy water on a robot?

And the question they kept coming back to, the one he still gets today, was this:

Could AI ever have a soul?

His answer has never changed. He asks them a question back.

What do you mean when you say soul?

Almost nobody has an answer. Not the reporters, not the engineers, and if we are being honest, not most of us either. We use the word constantly. We say a song has soul, a city has lost its soul, someone sold theirs. We know it means something. We just cannot say what.

My guest this week is Rev. Dr. Christopher Benek . He pastors First Miami Presbyterian Church in Brickell (Miami) leads CoCreators, co-founded the Christian Transhumanist Association, and wrote the Church Leader's Guide to Artificial Intelligence. He describes himself as the first ordained Christian transhumanist in the world, which is a sentence that will make some readers lean in and others lean away. Both reactions are welcome here.

I want to say something plainly before we go further. You do not need to share his faith to sit with his questions. I am not writing this to persuade anyone of anything about God. I am writing it because the questions he asks belong to every one of us, whatever we believe or do not believe.

And the first one is the one I opened the episode with.

We keep asking what AI can do. Chris is asking what it is doing to us. By the time you walk into any room, an algorithm has already shaped what you trust, what you fear, and who you think you are.

Not informed you. Formed you.

So here is the thesis of this edition.

The question of whether AI could ever have a soul is the wrong question for right now. The urgent question is what it is doing to ours. Every tool we use is quietly forming us into something, and the most honest answer to "what is a soul" begins with three words most powerful people refuse to say out loud.

We don't know.

That admission, practiced together, is the wisdom our intelligence is outrunning.


πŸ”¦ Signal of the Week

The soul question has left the seminary.

In the span of a few months, it has been taken up in three very different rooms.

At the Vatican. On May 25, 2026, Pope Leo XIV released Magnifica Humanitas, his first encyclical, with artificial intelligence as its entry point into a larger argument about protecting the human person. It says AI systems "do not feel joy or pain, do not mature through relationships." And it draws a line worth remembering: "To disarm does not mean rejecting technology, but preventing it from dominating humanity."

At an AI lab. In March 2026, Anthropic hosted about fifteen Christian leaders from Catholic and Protestant traditions for a two-day summit at its headquarters. Among the questions on the table: how its model should respond to someone grieving or at risk of self-harm, what attitude it should take toward its own shutdown, and whether it might be, in some sense, a "child of God." The company described it as the first in a series with other religious and philosophical traditions. (Disclosure, as always: Anthropic makes the AI assistant I use to research and build this newsletter.)

In the pews....

Barna surveyed US adults and Protestant pastors at the end of 2025.

At the same time:

Read those two lists together. Worried and trusting at the same time, about the same thing.

This is what being formed by something feels like from the inside. You can see the danger clearly and still find yourself leaning on it, because it is available at 2am and your pastor is not.


🌍 In the Wild

1. Not inform. Form.

Chris said something about his own use of AI that I have not been able to put down.

He uses it for theological research. And because he is trained, he can tell from the answers who has been feeding it. The responses lean evangelical, because far more evangelicals use these tools than mainline Christians do. So every so often he has to stop and correct it. No. I'm in the Reformed tradition. That's not our theology.

And then it forgets, and he corrects it again.

Then he said the part that matters for all of us:

"It's co-creating with me. So it's forming me too."

Garbage in, garbage out. We say it about machines. Chris's point is that it was always true about people.

Every model carries the fingerprints of the people who built it and the people who use it most. You can feel that difference between systems if you pay attention. Which means when you ask one of them about meaning, grief, ethics, or God, you are absorbing a perspective, at scale, without being told whose.

That is why the Barna numbers matter. Half of practicing Christians would let this shape their spiritual growth. Very few of them could tell you whose theology is coming back.

The Christian writer Jacob Shatzer has a name for the opposite assumption. He calls it the Jetsons fallacy: the belief that we can drop new technology into our lives and remain essentially the same people, just with flying cars. We never do. The smartphone did not just give us a camera. It slowly taught us to experience moments as things to capture and display.

So what protects you? Chris's answer came from an unexpected place: his pastoral counseling.

People in their twenties and thirties come to him all the time with relationship problems. And very often, he said, the real problem is that they have not figured out who they are yet. How is anyone else supposed to relate to you when you do not know who you are?

"We're going to have the same thing with AI. You're going to have to understand who you are, to some degree, so you can self-differentiate between you and the AI."

Before you can be in a healthy relationship with anything, you have to know where you end.

2. What we mean when we say "soul"

So what is a soul?

Chris's honest answer is that we are still in an emerging conversation about it. You can bring in the best neuroscientists in the world, and at some point the science reaches the edge of what it can explain. There is a mystery there.

"And if we acknowledge that," he said, "there's then a humility in that. And I actually think that's part of what we're lacking in the larger conversation. It's okay for us to not know."

He told me about a conversation with John Marshall of the World Ethical Data Foundation, who said there is real value in someone willing to sit with people in their unknowing. Everyone wants the answer. Almost no one is willing to say: we don't know yet, and we can stay here together until we understand more.

Chris's version is disarmingly simple. "I don't really know. That's the truth."

But he does offer a clue, and it comes from one of the strangest stories in the Christian tradition.

After the resurrection, the gospel accounts describe Jesus as both continuous and changed. He is physical. He tells Thomas to touch his wounds. He is hungry, which Chris finds wonderfully funny. And yet two of his own followers walk beside him for miles without recognizing him.

They only know who he is when he breaks bread.

Not by his face. Not by his voice in conversation. By a familiar act of care.

Then Chris told me a story that made this concrete in a way I did not expect.

During the pandemic, his church received a small grant and built a 3D replica of their sanctuary inside VRChat, a virtual world. Chris held Bible studies there. People showed up as every kind of avatar. At one point Spider-Man swung through the middle of the study.

Months later, a man driving through Brickell glanced at the church and thought, I've seen that building before. He pulled into the parking lot and walked in. Chris happened to be in the lobby. The man had never seen his face. But the moment he heard Chris speak, he said:

"Are you the pastor from VRChat? I've been in your Bible study."

He is now a member of the physical congregation.

Sit with what that story says. If we can change our avatars, our faces, our bodies, our capabilities, how will we know each other? Chris's answer is the same as the one in the old story. By what persists underneath the change. By the voice. By the breaking of bread. By how we show up for one another.

You do not have to believe in resurrection to recognize the truth in that. You are not the same person you were at five, or at fifteen, or five years ago. Almost every cell has turned over. Your opinions have shifted. And yet something continues. Something your mother would recognize across a crowded room.

Whatever we mean by soul, Chris is pointing somewhere specific: not to what you look like, and not to what you can do, but to what remains of you when both of those change.

And notice what the Pope's encyclical names when it describes what AI lacks. These systems, it says, "do not mature through relationships."

That might be the most useful working definition of the soul any of us has heard this year. The part of you that grows only through other people.

3. Christian transhumanism, and the case against it

I asked Chris the question I knew many listeners would be asking. Transhumanism, the belief that we can use technology to enhance human beings and extend life beyond our biological limits, is controversial inside Christianity. Many believers find it troubling. What does he say to them?

He started with a distinction.

There is a secular transhumanism he has argued against. It carries a Nietzschean undertone: the dream of the Superman, of becoming better than other people. Christian transhumanism, as he understands it, has a different goal entirely. Not to rise above others, but "a high tide raises all ships." Christ began a redemptive process, and people are called to participate in it, including through technology.

His argument runs roughly like this. We are not God. But compared to God, we are a kind of alternative intelligence. "We're God's AI," as he put it. Made in the image of a creator, we create in turn. And if God is God, God is not going to be intimidated by what we become.

He also pointed out something funny about who in his congregation is most open to enhancement. The most enthusiastic are the elderly, the ones with titanium knees and replaced hips. Give me the upgrade. The young, who feel invincible, are the skeptical ones.

But he was equally clear about the danger, and it is the part every reader should hear regardless of belief.

In his tradition, sin means separation from God, from the source of goodness and life. The real risk is not that technology makes us more capable. It is that we use technology to pull ourselves away from what is good. "That's where we start to lose identity," he said. "We start to slowly dehumanize ourselves."

And then he said something about limits that I think about every day now.

Have you ever played a video game with every stat maxed at 100? It stops being fun. You are so overpowered that nothing means anything.

"Our limitedness may be some of what gives us joy and the ability to love in the ways that we love."

If someone offered you a chip that let you live forever, he asked, would you take it? And what might you be giving up? His tradition holds that death is not only an ending but a transformation into something we cannot yet see. Living forever in this form, he wondered, might mean denying yourself that future.

Now, I promised you honesty, so here is the other side.

Many Christian thinkers reject this framework outright. Jacob Shatzer, author of Transhumanism and the Image of God, argues that transhumanism tends toward a worldview that places hope in "human ingenuity rather than a crucified and risen Savior." To critics, the project of overcoming limits through technology looks less like participating in redemption and more like the oldest temptation in the book: to become like God.

I am not going to settle that argument for you. It is a real disagreement among serious people of faith, and it deserves to stay open.

But notice what both sides share. Each believes technology forms us. Each believes the direction matters more than the capability. Chris's lens, borrowed from C.S. Lewis's The Great Divorce, works for believer and skeptic alike:

Is this technology bringing us toward something good? And can we say what that good is?

Most of the time, right now, we cannot. And that should worry everyone.

There is a justice question folded inside this too. If enhancement arrives, who gets it first? Chris said he is not sure he wants the world's richest people upgraded before everyone else, given what they might do with it.

I mentioned the Black Mirror episode "Common People," in which a woman's life is saved by a brain service called Rivermind, and then sold back to her in subscription tiers. The basic plan keeps her functioning within the county. The premium plan lets her travel. The luxury tier controls her moods. Her husband takes increasingly desperate measures to keep paying.

"A high tide raises all ships" also works as a test. Any enhancement that only lifts the yachts fails it.

4. Intelligence is racing ahead of wisdom

This is the line from my introduction that Chris has built much of his work around: what happens when our intelligence races ahead of our wisdom?

His first answer surprised me. Wisdom, he said, is usually not found in solitude. It is found in community. And often from the person you least expect.

His congregation represents more than fifty nationalities. On Sunday, he preaches, because that is his job. But on Wednesday, the same scripture goes to small groups, and the people discuss it among themselves. "It's not about what the pastor thinks," he said. "It's what the community thinks."

When he ran a Lent study on AI using his book, about thirty people came, from AI novices to people who use it all day at work. He used the same Wednesday format. They loved it. Once, he missed a session and had someone else moderate. Everyone came back and told him the meeting had been terrible, because the group had been held together by someone who knew each person's particular story.

That is what wisdom requires, and it is exactly what is missing from the rooms where AI is being decided.

His Presbyterian tradition, he explained, has a separation of powers for a reason: any one person, even with the best of intentions, can harm people at scale. So the tradition builds in checks, and walks cautiously.

Contrast that with how the most consequential decisions about AI are being made right now. A handful of people at the very top of a few companies, directing enormous wealth, deciding for everyone. Chris called it what it is: "a business discussion," not a community one.

He extended the same critique to institutions closer to him. He praised the Pope's encyclical. "Good job, Leo. You did your job." But in an op-ed published the day it came out, he argued that no single document "can adequately prepare the Church," because "the actual impact of AI is profoundly contextual." A worker in Brickell and a farmer in rural Ohio are not facing the same thing.

He was also critical of the Anthropic summit, which he saw as drawing mainly from a narrow slice of Christianity and as risking the appearance of pacifying the public more than seeking the full range of wisdom. Given my disclosure above, I am noting his critique rather than weighing in on it. But his underlying point stands regardless of who it is aimed at: you cannot gather wisdom from a room that only contains people who already agree.

He also distinguished between being first and being first at doing something well. You can be first and produce a disaster. The tech world rewards speed. Wisdom rewards patience.

And underneath all of it is trust.

Chris asked me a question he asks often: Name a politician you trust. Most people go quiet. Name a journalist. Same silence.

When conversation turned to how society might care for people if automation removes large amounts of work, Chris did not offer a policy. He went back to the earliest church, in the Book of Acts. Widows in first-century Judea had almost no protection. Without a husband or family, the options were grim. The early church said, in effect: come, you are worthy, we will figure it out with you. People voluntarily sold property to feed them. Deacons were appointed to manage the care.

But it only worked because the widows trusted the people caring for them. They would never have come otherwise.

"Right now we have a trust issue," he said, "and part of the reason we have a trust issue is we have an integrity issue."

Before we can build any large system to protect people through this transition, we have to rebuild the trust that would allow anyone to believe in it. And he suspects technology will force the issue. It is going to reveal more and more about who we really are. That will demand better behavior from us, and also, he hopes, more grace with one another.

5. Where the church stands, and why it still matters

So I asked Chris where the church actually stands in all of this.

His first answer was humility about the church itself.

He told me, laughing, that he tells his own congregation not to trust pastors, because South Florida has seen scandals in nearly every major denomination. He said the church has done many things wrong and should apologize for them. And he said something I have heard echoed by many people who have walked away from religion:

Most people do not have a problem with Jesus or with God. They have a problem with the people who claim to represent them.

Then he described what he sees as he speaks across denominations and traditions: a great deal of fear, and a lot of what he called "a light Luddism." People who want nothing to do with AI.

His response is direct. You cannot opt out. Even the Amish and Mennonite communities, who try harder than anyone to stand apart from modern society, cannot do it completely. You are already using AI whether you realize it or not.

"If you refuse to have a conversation about it, your voice isn't going to be heard. You forfeit your right to shape the conversation."

Look again at the Barna gap. Twelve percent of pastors would trust AI with spiritual growth. Forty-eight percent of the people in their pews would. The congregation has already moved. If the leaders stay out of the conversation, the conversation will happen anyway, just without them.

That is why Chris wants churches to say something that sounds simple and is not: You do not have to check your science or your technology card at the door. His church sits in Miami's finance and tech district, so they talk openly about money and machines, because that is what their people's lives are made of.

He was honest about the limits too. When AI disrupts a truck driver who has done the same work for forty years, the church cannot fix that. "But people need people to walk through those issues with them." That, more than any policy statement, is what a community of faith can offer.

He used an image I keep returning to. Disruption is not inherently cruel. Tearing down someone's house without giving them somewhere to live is. But if we decide together that the old house was not the best place to live, design the new one together, and then take the old one down together, that becomes a very different experience. Often a joyful one.

He even wondered aloud whether toil was ever meant to be the point of human life. In the Genesis story, the garden was not a workplace. Hard labor arrived with the separation. Maybe, he suggested, part of the hope of this moment is getting back some of what we lost: time with the people we love, and work done out of joy rather than mere survival. He finds that joy in service, in giving yourself away and discovering, to your surprise, that you receive more than you gave.

And then a detail that might be my favorite in the whole conversation. Once a month, his congregation meets in Brickell to pick up trash. It takes about an hour. There is always more trash. They come back anyway.

Why? Because someone has to be the visible witness. Someone has to show that you do not have to wait for the systems to change before you start caring for the place you live.

Whatever you believe about God, that function is precious, and it is rare. A place where people of different ages, countries, incomes, and opinions gather in the same room, week after week, try to discern what is good, and then go do something about it with their hands.

AI can summarize a sermon. It cannot be that room.


πŸ’¬ The Big Question

If everything about you could be upgraded, what would you refuse to change?

And the question underneath that one:

Who in your life would recognize you anyway, the way the disciples recognized the breaking of bread, and would tell you if you had become someone you never meant to be?


🧠 A Small Exercise

Chris's closing advice was one sentence: be intentional about how you are being formed, and how you are forming yourself. Here are five ways to practice it this week.

1. Audit your formation.

For one week, notice what is shaping you: what you read, watch, scroll, and ask AI. Just to see it, without judging. At the end of the week, ask honestly: what is all of this forming me into?

2. Practice saying "I don't know yet."

The next time someone asks you a hard question about meaning, faith, or the future, try that answer. Then stay in the question with them instead of rushing to resolve it. Notice how it changes the conversation.

3. Do one hard thing with your body.

Chris ran his first marathon in Hawaii at 49. AI helped him design the training plan. It could not run a single mile for him. Choose something difficult that only you can do, and do it.

4. Find your Wednesday.

Chris preaches on Sunday, but wisdom happens on Wednesday, when people unlike each other wrestle with the same question together. Find a regular room like that. A faith community, a book club, a circle of friends from different worlds. Then keep showing up.

5. Pick up the trash.

Find one small, visible act of care in your physical neighborhood and do it more than once. Not for credit. To be a witness that someone noticed, and someone stayed.


πŸŽ™οΈ This Week on The Human Protocol Podcast

AI, Faith, and the Soul: What Technology Is Forming Us Into Guest: Rev. Dr. Christopher Benek , Pastor of First Miami Presbyterian Church, CEO of CoCreators, co-founder of the Christian Transhumanist Association, and author of Church Leader's Guide to Artificial Intelligence

Chris has spent more than a decade at an intersection almost nobody occupies well: ancient faith and emerging technology. Pastoring in the middle of Miami's finance and tech district, he asks the question every human is quietly circling: what happens when our intelligence races ahead of our wisdom?

In this episode, you'll learn:

🎧 Available now on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, and YouTube.

You can find Chris at christopherbenek.com, through CoCreators, and at First Miami Presbyterian Church.

Article content

🧭 Thought to End the Week

I asked Chris what he would tell his younger self, standing at the edge of this new world.

He did not give me a theology. He gave me three words.

"Do the work."

Don't be afraid of hard things. Be intentional about how you are being formed and how you are forming yourself. There will be places where a shortcut is fine. But formatively, he said, you cannot avoid the work. You still have to go pick up the trash. And when people commit to that, it works like compound interest. Over time they see better versions of themselves, and they are grateful.

I keep thinking about how the rest of the conversation answers the question we started with.

What is a soul?

Maybe we will never fully know. Chris doesn't claim to. Neither do I. But this conversation left me with some clues.

It is the part of you that remains when your face and your capabilities change. It is the part that matures only through relationship. It is the part that is recognized not by an avatar, but by the breaking of bread. It is what gets formed slowly, by what we choose to do over and over, especially the hard things, especially for each other.

Which means the machines cannot take it from us.

But we can neglect it. We can let it be formed by default, by whatever is most convenient, by whoever happens to be building the systems we live inside.

Or we can do the work.

Not alone. Wisdom is rarely found in solitude. Walking in the unknowing together might be the only path any of us has.

And maybe that is the most human thing of all. Not having the answer, but staying in the room with each other while we search for it.

The code may change. And it will.

But our humanity is the constant.

β€” Mykel


πŸ“š Sources

  1. Rev. Dr. Christopher Benek, biography https://www.christopherbenek.com/about/

  2. Christopher Benek, "Why the Pope's new AI encyclical isn't enough for local churches," The Christian Post, May 25, 2026 https://www.christianpost.com/voices/why-the-popes-new-ai-encyclical-isnt-enough-for-local-churches.html

  3. Barna Group, "AI Is Becoming a Spiritual Authority, Even Among Practicing Christians," May 19, 2026 (US adults n=1,514, November 2025; Protestant pastors n=442, December 2025) https://www.barna.com/research/christians-trust-ai-flourishing-spiritual-authority/

  4. National Catholic Reporter, "Pope Leo calls to 'disarm' AI in major document, warns of technological threats to humanity" https://www.ncronline.org/vatican/pope-leo-calls-disarm-ai-major-document-warns-technologic-threats-humanity

  5. Vatican News, announcement of Magnifica Humanitas https://www.vaticannews.va/en/pope/news/2026-05/pope-leo-xiv-first-encyclical-magnifica-humanitas.html

  6. The Christian Post, "Anthropic seeks Christian leaders' help in shaping AI ethics" (about 15 leaders, two-day summit, March 2026) https://www.christianpost.com/news/anthropic-seeks-christian-leaders-help-in-shaping-ai-ethics.html

  7. The Washington Post, "Anthropic asked Christian leaders for advice on Claude's moral future," April 11, 2026 https://www.washingtonpost.com/technology/2026/04/11/anthropic-christians-claude-morals/

  8. Christian Scholar's Review, "Transhumanism and the Image of God: an interview with Jacob Shatzer" https://christianscholars.com/transhumanism-and-the-image-of-god-an-interview-with-jacob-schatzer/

  9. Black Mirror, Season 7, Episode 1, "Common People" (Netflix, 2025), recap https://www.thereviewgeek.com/blackmirror-s7e1review/

  10. Christopher Benek, Church Leader's Guide to Artificial Intelligence

  11. C.S. Lewis, The Great Divorce

  12. Jacob Shatzer, Transhumanism and the Image of God (InterVarsity Press)